Trade War

Trilateral meeting

Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump meet in Shenzhen on 19 November 2026, the first meeting of its kind. What the three-way format brings into trade beyond the separate US-China talks: a waived US tariff on Russian oil buyers, China-Russia trade and payments, and oil prices tied to the Iran war.

Assessment dated 19 November 2026

LiveRussian bombers enter Taiwan's air defence zoneAll updates

The Chinese, Russian and US presidents meet in Shenzhen on Thursday 19 November 2026, on the margins of the APEC summit, at the Kylin Villa guesthouse. The Kremlin spokesman, Dmitry Peskov, said no more than an hour had been set aside.17 CNBC reported low expectations of concrete results.1 Mr Trump held a separate meeting of about 40 minutes with Mr Putin earlier the same day.17 24 Mr Xi and Mr Trump then met for about an hour. This page was updated on 19 November, before the three-way meeting ended; no government had published an account of it.24 It sets out the trade questions that involve Russia, and so reach beyond the Trump-Xi talks on the US-China truce, and the dates that will show whether anything changed.

Oil-buyer tariffA 100% US tariff on goods from the five largest buyers of Russian oil, ordered on 16 October 2026 and waived with no end date.5
China-Russia tradeUS$242.49 billion in January to October 2026, up 32.1%, already more than all of 2025.8
OutcomeNot yet known. Moscow hoped for a joint statement; if none is agreed, each side will give its own account.3

Live updates, 19 November (Shenzhen time, newest first)

  1. News

    Russian bombers enter Taiwan's air defence zone

    Taiwan's defence ministry says two Russian Tu-95 aircraft entered its air defence identification zone from the south, flew east of the island and left north-east of Keelung. An ADIZ is a buffer area beyond territorial airspace. On Tuesday Japan protested that two suspected Russian aircraft had violated its airspace, and South Korea also scrambled jets. Moscow has not commented.19 27

  2. Breaking

    Putin arrives at the Kylin Villa; three-way talks due shortly

    Mr Putin has arrived at the villa, CCTV reports. Dozens of journalists are waiting, and CCTV's feed earlier showed about a dozen soldiers marching to the plaza outside, apparently to welcome the Russian delegation.19

  3. Breaking

    Putin on his way to the Kylin Villa

    Mr Putin has left his hotel for the Kylin Villa, where he will join Mr Xi and Mr Trump, China's state broadcaster CCTV reports; its live feed shows cars flying Russian flags on the road.19

  4. News

    Taiwan watches the talks

    Taiwan said on Wednesday it was in "close contact" with the US before the three-way talks. US arms sales to the island remain a main point of friction between Washington and Beijing. Taiwan sits in APEC as an economy, not a country.19 Earlier in the afternoon Taiwan's defence ministry reported two Russian Tu-95 bombers flying east of the island.27

  5. Breaking

    Xi and Trump at lunch; three-way talks yet to begin

    The US press pool says Mr Xi is having lunch with Mr Trump at the Kylin Villa. The three-way meeting, scheduled for 14:30, has not started, and the schedule is badly delayed.19

  6. News

    China's Commerce Ministry: farm working group to meet soon

    The ministry's spokesman, He Yadong, said the agriculture working group under the new US-China trade council will hold its first meeting "in the near future". No date was given. The council itself first met by video on 13 November. Earlier Mr Trump said he would ask China to "do more for American farmers".30 27

  7. Analysis

    Laura Bicker: a difficult balance for China over Ukraine

    The BBC's China correspondent writes that Beijing wants the war over but does not want Russia to lose, and so is resisting putting Ukraine on the agenda; with Mr Trump and Mr Putin both saying it will come up, it may be hard for Mr Xi to avoid.19

  8. News

    Xi likens US-China ties to Shenzhen's rise

    Mr Xi told Mr Trump that Shenzhen grew from a fishing village into a metropolis in just over 40 years, and called a constructive China-US relationship "a pioneering undertaking without precedent".19

  9. News

    Russia shows the hall; three-way talks still ahead

    Russia's foreign ministry spokeswoman, Maria Zakharova, showed the hall where the three leaders will meet. Gazeta.Ru, citing RT, said the three-way talks were still to come.29

  10. Analysis

    Chinese media reject the "Yalta 2.0" label

    BBC Monitoring reports that Chinese media and scholars call the comparison "outdated Cold War thinking" and say a carve-up of spheres of influence would run against a UN-centred order.19

  11. News

    Trump-Xi meeting ends after about an hour

    China's state broadcaster CCTV reported the end of the meeting, as carried by NBC News and Nikkei Asia. No account of its content has been released.24 27

  12. Analysis

    Laura Bicker: Xi needs stability because China relies on exports

    The BBC correspondent reads Mr Xi's warm tone through trade: he will not want a return to the tariffs that almost halted US-China trade. Mr Trump said the two had talked for two hours at the banquet the night before.19

  13. News

    Xi: a "new definition" of the relationship

    Mr Xi said the two had given relations "new substance based on respect, fairness and reciprocity" and had "established a new definition of a constructive China-US relationship of strategic stability", Reuters reported.19

  14. News

    Kremlin: Ukraine was the main topic with Trump

    The Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov said the 35 to 40 minutes of talks centred on Ukraine and also covered US-Russia relations; "neither side made any particularly important statements".27 19

  15. News

    Xi: ties "overall stable and improving"

    Mr Xi said he was willing to keep steering relations "on the correct course".27

  16. News

    Trump: the trade board "has brought balance"

    Opening his meeting with Mr Xi, Mr Trump said the "U.S.-China Board of Trade has brought balance to the relationship", that tariffs had been split "in fair ways", and that energy must keep flowing through the Strait of Hormuz.27 24

  17. News

    Trump and Xi begin talks at the Kylin Villa

    Chinese state media reported the start of the meeting, as carried by NBC News. The finance ministers of Russia and the US had sat in on the Trump-Putin talks earlier, TASS reports.24 25

  18. News

    Trump-Putin talks end after about 40 minutes

    NBC News reported the end of the meeting. Mr Ushakov called it "a good meeting".24

  19. News

    Trump: "wonderful things can come out of this"

    Facing reporters with Mr Putin, Mr Trump said they had had a "great relationship for many years" and that they would have "a second meeting later on".19

  20. Breaking

    Trump and Putin meet in a "pull-aside"

    Instead of meeting Mr Xi first, Mr Trump began talking to Mr Putin at the APEC venue, with press access restricted, according to the White House pool.19

  21. Research

    Researchers in all three countries reject "new Yalta"

    Wu Xinbo (Fudan), Fyodor Lukyanov (Valdai Club) and Susan Thornton (Yale) told The Paper the meeting will not divide spheres of influence. Thornton hopes it lays the ground for a lasting US-China economic agreement.20

  22. Research

    CSIS: a three-way nuclear statement is "a long shot"

    Heather Williams suggests US-China missile launch notifications and a date for a further meeting as realistic steps.21

  23. Research

    An informal steering committee?

    Alexander Korolev (UNSW) argues the three are acting as "an informal steering committee for global affairs", at the expense of other countries.23

Times are Shenzhen time (GMT+8), converted from each outlet's live coverage; BBC entries were supplied by a reader from the BBC live page. "Before" marks research published before the meeting. The three-way meeting was scheduled for 14:30.28

19 November: the day of the meeting

  • Format. France 24 calls it the first meeting of its kind between leaders of the three countries. It is held at the Kylin Villa in Shenzhen and was due to last no more than an hour, according to Mr Peskov; on the day Mr Ushakov said the leaders themselves would decide how long it runs. Mr Ushakov said agreed delegations would attend and that work on a possible communique was continuing, TASS reports.17 24 28 The meeting did not begin on time: at about 15:15 local time Russia's foreign ministry spokeswoman, Maria Zakharova, was still showing the hall where it would take place, and the Russian news site Gazeta.Ru reported, citing RT, that the three-way talks were still to come.29
  • Trump and Putin. Shortly before noon local time, when Mr Trump had been expected to meet Mr Xi, the White House press pool reported that he was instead talking to Mr Putin in a "pull-aside" discussion at the centre where the APEC plenary had been held that morning, with press access restricted.19 17 In front of reporters Mr Trump said the two had had a "great relationship for many years" and that "a lot of wonderful things can come out of this, or at least start". He added: "We'll have a second meeting later on as you probably know, but we'll have this right now and it'll be great." The talks then continued behind closed doors and ended after about 40 minutes, NBC News reported; Mr Ushakov then told Russian state media that the talks had lasted 35 to 40 minutes, that the main topic had been settling the war in Ukraine and that US-Russia relations had also been discussed, that "it was a good meeting", and that "neither side made any particularly important statements". He said Mr Putin was in an excellent mood afterwards.19 24
  • Who sat in. TASS reports that the Russian side included the foreign minister, Sergei Lavrov, the finance minister, Anton Siluanov, the Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov and the investment envoy Kirill Dmitriev; the US side included the secretary of state, Marco Rubio, and the Treasury secretary, Scott Bessent. Both finance ministers took part, but neither side has said whether sanctions or trade came up.25
  • Trump and Xi. Mr Trump and Mr Xi began their own meeting at about 13:35 local time at the Kylin Villa, where the three-way meeting follows, NBC News reported, citing Chinese state media. In front of reporters Mr Trump said that "both the United States and China have an interest in ensuring that energy flows through the Strait of Hormuz", that Iran "cannot have a nuclear weapon", and that the two were looking to help with the war between Russia and Ukraine. Mr Xi told him that the two leaders had given relations "new substance based on respect, fairness and reciprocity", and that "we have established a new definition of a constructive China-US relationship of strategic stability", as Reuters reported and the BBC carried. He called ties "overall stable" and "improving", and said he was willing to keep "steering China-US relations on the correct course".24 19 He likened the task to Shenzhen's growth from a fishing village into a metropolis in just over 40 years, calling a constructive China-US relationship "a pioneering undertaking without precedent".19 Mr Trump said the two had talked for two hours at the APEC banquet the night before.19 On trade, Mr Trump said the "U.S.-China Board of Trade has brought balance to the relationship", that tariffs had been split "in fair ways", and that he would ask China to "do more for American farmers", Nikkei Asia reported. Neither leader mentioned the truce, which ends on 10 January 2027, in public.27 The meeting ended at about 14:50 local time, after about an hour, NBC News and Nikkei Asia reported, citing the Chinese state broadcaster CCTV, which pushed the three-way meeting past its 14:30 slot; no account of its content had been released when this page was updated.24 27
  • Agenda. China has said only that the three will hold "in-depth exchanges on safeguarding world peace and promoting strategic stability in major-power relations", AFP reports.26 The White House says Mr Trump plans to discuss the war with Iran and a possible three-way nuclear arms agreement. US officials first said Ukraine would not be raised; Mr Trump later said it would. Ukraine's foreign minister, Andriy Sybiga, said he hoped Mr Xi and Mr Trump would put "pressure on Russia to end the war".17 18
  • At the APEC session. Mr Putin called partnership with APEC economies "Russia's strategic course", urged use of Russian logistics routes and said Moscow supports the draft leaders' statement. Mr Xi called open cooperation "essential" to the region's development.17

Trade is in the background. Al Jazeera notes that the Busan truce has been extended to 10 January 2027 and, citing the Center for Strategic and International Studies, that China's rare earth exports to the US are still about 75% below normal. Deborah Elms of the Hinrich Foundation said a handshake without incident would be seen as a win; Vuk Vuksanovic of King's College London said the meeting is "a far cry from being a new Yalta".18

The BBC's China correspondent, Laura Bicker, reads Mr Xi's tone through trade: with China's economy heavily reliant on exports, he needs a stable relationship and will not want a return to the tariffs that almost brought US-China trade to a standstill. She expects talk of ending the Ukraine war in the three-way meeting to be tricky, because Mr Xi fears for China's relations with Europe.19 She also writes that China is resisting putting the Ukraine war on the agenda: Beijing wants the war over but does not want Russia to lose, and European frustration is growing that Mr Xi does not press Moscow harder, not least over Chinese purchases of Russian oil and gas.19

What researchers say

Scholars in all three countries reject the comparison with the 1945 Yalta conference, at which the wartime powers divided Europe into spheres of influence. Wu Xinbo, who directs the Center for American Studies at Fudan University, told The Paper that the meeting will not divide spheres of influence and should be seen as the start of a political process, not a result. Fyodor Lukyanov of Russia's Valdai Club and Susan Thornton, a former US acting assistant secretary of state for East Asia, made the same point in the same roundtable.20 BBC Monitoring reports that Chinese media and scholars more broadly have called the Yalta comparison "outdated Cold War thinking", arguing that a carve-up of spheres of influence would run against a UN-centred order and China's call for a multipolar world.19

Alexander Korolev of the University of New South Wales takes a less comfortable view. He argues that the meeting shows the three acting as "an informal steering committee for global affairs", and that Beijing, for all its talk of a multipolar world, is accepting diplomacy centred on major powers to the exclusion of others.23

  • Trade. Ms Thornton hopes the US-China talks can lay the foundation for a lasting economic agreement, and expects Russia's economic difficulties to come up between Mr Trump and Mr Putin. Mr Wu links fading US interest in APEC to rising US protectionism over the past ten years.20
  • Russia and the US. Mr Lukyanov said substantive US-Russia cooperation is unlikely until the Ukraine war is settled, and that Russia-China relations will not be affected by either country's relations with Washington.20
  • Nuclear arms. Heather Williams of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) calls a three-way joint statement "still a long shot" because of China's reluctance to join any trilateral format. Her suggested first steps include an agreement on missile launch notifications between Washington and Beijing and a date for the next three-way meeting.21
  • China's record on the question. Daryl Kimball of the Arms Control Association notes that when Mr Trump met Mr Xi on 24 September 2026 the White House said he had advocated three-way arms control talks, and the Chinese account did not mention it. Beijing has rejected the trilateral approach since 2019 and proposes a no-first-use agreement among nuclear-armed states instead.22

All four pieces were written before the meeting. Of the six researchers quoted, three are based in the US, one in China, one in Russia and one in Australia.

What was said on 18 November

China's account of the Xi-Putin meeting has Mr Xi asking for a more stable and predictable environment for investment and business between the two countries, and protection of both countries' companies.2

At the APEC business summit Mr Putin said sanctions, tariffs and export restrictions still hold growth back, and that the share of dollars and euros in payments for Russian exports had fallen from 85% in 2021 to 9%. Those are his figures. He said he expected "great potential benefit" from the three-way meetings.4

The Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov said Mr Putin would brief Mr Xi on recent contacts with the US, including talks in Abu Dhabi.3

A US tariff on Russian oil buyers, written and waived

Executive Order 14436 of 16 October 2026 raises duties by 100% on goods from any of the five largest importers of Russian crude oil or gas that knowingly makes new purchases on or after 18 October, then waives the increase until the president or the secretary of state decides further action is appropriate.5

The order names no country. The law firm Davis Polk, crediting Senate aides as reported by Reuters, lists China, India, Slovakia, Hungary and Azerbaijan as the five largest buyers of Russian crude. That list is not a US government finding.6

China's Commerce Ministry said on 19 September 2026 that it opposes unilateral sanctions without UN authorisation and secondary sanctions on third countries, and reserves the right to take necessary measures.7

China-Russia trade and how it is paid for

China-Russia trade, January to October 2026US$ billion, Chinese customs figures
Show these figures as a table
ItemValueNote
China's imports from Russia$133.23bn
China's exports to Russia$109.26bn

Sources: 8

The yuan accounted for 20.8% of payments for Russian exports to "friendly" countries in June 2026, down from 45.2% in May 2024, according to Bank of Russia data reported from a Bloomberg analysis.14 On 16 November 2026 the European Union added nearly 50 Russian banks and financial institutions to its sanctions lists.15 16

Oil prices and the Iran war

Brent crude settled at US$95.84 a barrel on 13 November, after a 16% fall the week before, as Washington said it would keep its blockade of Iran in place. Phil Flynn of Price Futures Group told CNBC the fear had turned from shortage to "a surplus". Iran's military said four tankers were hit in the Strait of Hormuz on 12 November; Reuters could not verify that.9

Critical minerals stay in the bilateral channel

Rare earths belong to the Trump-Xi talks. China has paused its export controls on some critical minerals until 10 January 2027. The International Energy Agency puts China's share of refined magnet rare earth output at 91%.10

What third countries are watching

Brookings Institution scholars say European governments are watching closely. Constanze Stelzenmüller writes that Europeans fear a US-China deal could push Chinese surplus capacity towards their market, or that the two could set trade rules for everyone else. Ryan Hass writes that the main question is whether the US-China truce is extended.11

Dates to watch

DateWhat
19 November 2026The three-way meeting, about one hour: a joint statement or three separate accounts
21 November 2026Reported expiry of the US licence letting Hungary's MOL buy oil from Lukoil
29 November 2026Next meeting of seven OPEC+ producers, Russia among them
10 January 2027End of China's minerals pause and, Ryan Hass notes, of the US-China truce
Every 180 daysUS list of the five largest buyers of Russian oil; none found published by 18 November

Sources: 3 12 13 10 11 6

Method and limits

  • The page was last updated on 19 November 2026, before the three-way meeting ended, and will be updated once the three governments give their accounts. Live reports are attributed to the outlet that carried them.17
  • Figures are attributed to whoever gave them: Mr Putin's payment shares are his own, and the list of top Russian oil buyers comes from Senate aides via a law firm, not from the US government.4 6
  • The Hungary licence date rests on a November 2025 TASS report citing Bloomberg; this site did not see the Treasury document.12

Sources for this page

  1. Trump arrives in China for historic meeting with Xi, Putin
    CNBC · 18 November 2026
  2. 详讯丨习近平会见俄罗斯总统普京 [Xi Jinping meets Russian President Putin]
    The Paper (澎湃新闻), carrying Xinhua · 18 November 2026
  3. В Кремле рассказали о подготовке переговоров лидеров России, США и Китая [The Kremlin describes preparations for talks between the leaders of Russia, the US and China]
    Expert (Эксперт) · 16 November 2026
  4. Что Путин заявил на деловом саммите АТЭС в Шэньчжэне [What Putin said at the APEC business summit in Shenzhen]
    Vedomosti (Ведомости) · 18 November 2026
  5. Implementing the Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act of 2026 (Executive Order 14436)
    The White House · 16 October 2026
  6. New Russia sanctions law enacted: what you need to know
    Davis Polk · 2 October 2026
  7. 商务部新闻发言人就美方将《2026年格雷厄姆制裁俄罗斯和伊朗法案》签署成法答记者问 [Commerce Ministry spokesperson answers a question on the US signing the 2026 Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act into law]
    Ministry of Commerce of China · 19 September 2026
  8. 中国海关总署:前10个月中俄贸易额逾2400亿美元,超去年全年总额 [China customs: China-Russia trade passes US$240 billion in ten months, more than all of last year]
    Sputnik (卫星通讯社) · 10 November 2026
  9. Oil prices set for second weekly decline as Trump to stay with Iran blockade
    CNBC · 13 November 2026
  10. China extends pause on rare earth export curbs for two months
    The National · 9 November 2026
  11. 布鲁金斯学会专家研判深圳APEC期间中俄美元首会晤对国际秩序的影响 [Brookings experts assess what the China-Russia-US leaders' meeting during APEC in Shenzhen means for the international order]
    Huxiu, carrying a translation by IPP评论 of a Brookings Institution commentary · 16 November 2026
  12. US licensed Hungary's MOL to buy oil from Lukoil for one year, Bloomberg
    TASS · 25 November 2025
  13. Saudi Arabia, Russia, Iraq, Kuwait, Kazakhstan, Algeria, and Oman reaffirm commitment to market stability
    OPEC · 1 November 2026
  14. Россия провалила план по замене доллара на юань в торговле [Russia has failed in its plan to replace the dollar with the yuan in trade]
    The Moscow Times, Russian service · 11 November 2026
  15. Ukraine: EU lists 113 individuals and entities to further restrict Russia's ability to finance its war of aggression
    Council of the European Union · 16 November 2026
  16. Евросоюз ввел новые санкции против почти 50 банков: список [EU introduces new sanctions against almost 50 banks: the list]
    Sravni · 16 November 2026
  17. Xi-Trump-Putin talks live: China, US and Russia leaders to hold landmark three-way meeting
    France 24 · 19 November 2026
  18. What do Trump, Putin and Xi want from their Shenzhen meeting?
    Al Jazeera · 19 November 2026
  19. Live coverage of the Shenzhen meetings, entries on the Trump-Putin talks
    BBC News · 19 November 2026
  20. 圆桌|中俄美元首历史性首次会晤在即,三国权威学者谈大国关系新契机
    The Paper (澎湃新闻) · 17 November 2026
  21. Trilateral "Denuclearization": False Promises or Way Forward?
    Center for Strategic and International Studies · 9 November 2026
  22. Trump, Xi, Putin Failing to Tackle the Nuclear Threat
    Arms Control Association (Arms Control Today) · October 2026
  23. Xi-Trump-Putin Summit: When Great Powers Want to Call All the Shots, What Does It Mean for Everyone Else?
    The China-Global South Project, republishing The Conversation · 19 November 2026
  24. Live updates: Trump sits down with Putin ahead of historic trilateral talks with Xi
    NBC News · 19 November 2026
  25. Lavrov, Siluanov, Ushakov, Dmitriev attend Putin-Trump meeting
    TASS · 19 November 2026
  26. Xi, Trump meet in China ahead of trilateral with Putin
    Dawn, carrying AFP · 19 November 2026
  27. APEC live: Crunch day begins, with Trump set to meet Xi, Putin
    Nikkei Asia · 19 November 2026
  28. Putin-Xi-Trump meeting in China's Shenzhen scheduled for 6:30 a.m. GMT
    TASS · 19 November 2026
  29. Встреча Путина, Трампа и Си Цзиньпина. Онлайн
    Mail.ru News, live blog carrying Gazeta.Ru · 19 November 2026
  30. 商务部:中美贸易理事会农业工作组将于近期召开首次会议
    China News Service (中新网), carrying Xinhua · 19 November 2026