Each side's view
How Beijing, Washington, Tokyo, Seoul, Hanoi, Taipei, Ottawa, Brasília, New Delhi, Jakarta, Mexico City and Brussels each describe the tariffs, from sources in their own languages, with every item labelled by camp.
This page reports what each government and its commentators say, from sources in their own languages. Each item is labelled with the camp it speaks for. A camp's statement is its position, not an established fact; where the camps contradict each other, both are shown.
China
China's camp · government: Ministry of Commerce, 27 July 2026 · source in Chinese
Beijing calls the July tariffs unilateral and says Washington made a promise. Four days after the forced-labour tariffs took effect, a Commerce Ministry spokesperson said China has always opposed forced labour, noted that the United States has not ratified the 1930 Forced Labour Convention, and called the tariffs unilateralism and protectionism. The spokesperson said the US had clearly promised in the trade talks that replacement tariffs on Chinese goods would not exceed 20%, that the rate is now 12.5%, and that China's first round of countermeasures remains in force.48 49
中方敦促美方纠正错误做法,彻底取消有关单边关税措施。
China urges the US side to correct its wrong practice and completely cancel the unilateral tariff measures concerned.
美方在中美经贸磋商中明确承诺,对中国商品的替代加征关税不会超过20%。
The US side clearly promised in the China–US economic and trade consultations that replacement tariffs on Chinese goods would not exceed 20%.
China's camp · government: Customs Tariff Commission, 9 November 2026 · source in Chinese
The truce extension comes with a stated condition. The notice keeps the 24-point tariff suspended for two more months from 13:01 on 10 November 2026 and keeps the 10% rate. It records that the US has said several times that it intends to replace the struck-down emergency tariffs with Section 301 tariffs, and says China will adjust its countermeasures “as circumstances require”. The transport ministry's notice the same day gives 10 January 2027 as the end date for the pause on port fees.47
China's camp · press and trade press, November 2026 · source in Chinese
Before Shenzhen, Beijing kept its cards. The rare-earth pause was renewed one day before it expired and for two months only, which Chinese trade press read as keeping leverage for the leaders' meeting. China's foreign ministry confirmed the three-way meeting with the US and Russian presidents for 19 November.74 76
China's camp · party newspaper commentary, 5 August 2026; university chronology · source in Chinese
The party paper asks for a longer “cooperation list”. A People's Daily commentary under the pen name Zhong Sheng, used for the paper's line on foreign affairs, argued that the two economies need a longer list of cooperation and not a “covered list”, a reference to a US communications regulator's list restricting foreign power inverters and advanced robotics. It urged Washington to heed business on both sides. Tsinghua University's finance centre keeps a running Chinese-language chronology of the dispute.91 93
China's camp · commentators: a brokerage economist, a state news site, a university institute · source in Chinese
Chinese analysts read the Supreme Court ruling as limited. Luo Zhiheng of Yuekai Securities expected the effective tariff to fall only slightly and doubted refunds would be generous. A commentary on a state news site noted that many tariffs on China rest on Sections 232 and 301 and were untouched; it quoted an estimate that the weighted average US tariff on Chinese goods would fall from 32% to 24%. A Fudan University institute described US trade policy as caught in a cycle of lost legality, emergency replacement and renewed dispute. One commentary argued that the ruling strengthened China's hand in the talks.50 51 52
United States
United States' camp · government: Office of the US Trade Representative, 23 July 2026
Washington presents the tariffs as a response to forced labour abroad. The Trade Representative found that 54 economies had no prohibition on importing goods made with forced labour and six had one but did not enforce it, and imposed 10% or 12.5%. The administration has also said publicly that it means to rebuild under other statutes what the Supreme Court removed.3 4
President Trump recognizes that decades of moral suasion have not eradicated forced labor from global supply chains.
Ambassador Jamieson Greer, US Trade Representative, 23 July 2026.
I am encouraged by the trading partners who have moved quickly to adopt forced labor import prohibitions.
The same statement; the 17 economies charged 10% are those Washington credits with progress.
United States' camp · legislature's research service and law firms
American lawyers doubt the legal footing. The Congressional Research Service records the argument that using Section 301 against sixty economies at once raises the same “major questions” problem that defeated the emergency tariffs, and the new tariffs are under challenge in the trade court.27 2
Japan
Japan's camp · government: trade minister and the state trade agency · source in Japanese
Tokyo calls the measure regrettable and stresses the cap. Japan's trade agency reports that Japanese goods pay the ordinary duty or 12.5%, whichever is higher, and that cars, steel and pharmaceuticals covered by sector tariffs are outside the measure. The trade minister, Akazawa Ryosei, was reported as calling it regrettable (遺憾) that Japan was taxed for lacking an import ban on forced-labour goods. In June he had said he confirmed with the US commerce secretary that no tariff beyond last year's agreement would be imposed. The ministry's own page could not be opened for this site, so the minister's words are given as reported.53 54
South Korea
South Korea's camp · press reporting the trade ministry, 24 July 2026 · source in Korean
Seoul's line is a 15% ceiling on everything combined. Korean reports say the government obtained Washington's reconfirmation that the forced-labour and excess-capacity tariffs together will not exceed 15%, the rate in the 2025 deal. With 12.5% now imposed, that leaves 2.5 points for the second investigation. The ministry judged that uncertainty over US tariffs had partly eased.55 56
정부가 미국으로부터 강제노동 및 과잉생산 관련 무역법 301조 관세를 합산해 총 15%를 넘지 않는다는 기존 한미 무역합의를 재확인받았다.
The government received reconfirmation from the United States of the existing Korea–US trade agreement that Section 301 tariffs on forced labour and overcapacity, added together, will not exceed 15% in total.
Vietnam
Vietnam's camp · state media reporting the Ministry of Industry and Trade, 26 July 2026 · source in Vietnamese
Hanoi answers with dialogue, not retaliation. Vietnam is among the 38 economies charged 12.5%. The state news agency says the tariff falls on about 37% of Vietnam's current exports to the United States once exempt goods are removed, and that the trade ministry will keep working with the Trade Representative. Related reports carry the official position that Vietnam strictly forbids all forms of forced labour and that the US finding does not reflect the facts. The party newspaper points out that the Section 122 tariff lasted 150 days while the Section 301 tariff has no end date, and that two more US investigations, on excess capacity and intellectual property, are still open.57 58
Việt Nam thuộc nhóm 38 quốc gia và vùng lãnh thổ Hoa Kỳ áp dụng mức thuế 12,5%
Vietnam is in the group of 38 countries and territories to which the United States applies the 12.5% rate.
Bộ Công Thương sẽ tiếp tục làm việc với USTR và các cơ quan liên quan của Hoa Kỳ
The Ministry of Industry and Trade will continue to work with USTR and the relevant US agencies.
Mexico
Mexico's camp · press reporting the Economy Ministry · source in Spanish
Mexico City stresses what is exempt. The Economy Ministry said goods that meet the rules of the North American agreement would not pay the forced-labour tariff, and that it would hold formal talks with the Trade Representative on the remaining 15% of exports. Mexico maintains that it already bans imports made with forced labour. President Sheinbaum asked for patience and said Section 301 is separate from the tariffs already applied to Mexico. A fourth round of the agreement's review was agreed but, by mid-October, had no date.59 60
European Union
European Union's camp · German trade agency; Swiss and Belgian press reporting the Commission · source in German and French
Brussels calls the tariff unjustified and watches the 15% ceiling. German-language reports say the Commission rejected the US finding: the EU has had a regulation barring forced-labour goods from its market since late 2024 and had agreed in the trade deal to act jointly with Washington. A deputy spokesperson called tariffs on that ground unjustified. Germany's trade agency sets out the mechanics: 10% in total including the ordinary duty, and no addition where the ordinary duty is already 10% or more. The Swiss daily that reported the Commission's reaction says the question for Europe is whether the agreed 15% ceiling still holds. French-language reports have the trade commissioner, Maroš Šefčovič, wanting talks on steel and aluminium reopened. The European Parliament twice put the 2025 deal on hold, but the implementing law was agreed on 19 May 2026 and then passed. Brussels has set a year-end deadline: if US duties on steel and aluminium products stay above 15%, it may suspend its own concessions.68 67 61 108 107 109
Taiwan
Taiwan's camp · government: Executive Yuan, 24 July 2026 · source in Chinese
Taipei presents its rate as a win. The cabinet says Taiwan received 10% with the ordinary duty included, the same treatment as the EU, because Washington recognised commitments on forced-labour imports that Taiwan made in its reciprocal trade agreement. It calls this better than the earlier Section 122 surcharge, which was 10% on top of the ordinary duty. It adds that the excess-capacity result is still to come and that the final rate remains Washington's to decide.62 63
我國獲10%且不疊加MFN相對優惠待遇
Our country obtained the relatively favourable treatment of 10% without stacking on the MFN duty.
美方尚未公布「結構性產能過剩」301調查結果
The US side has not yet published the result of the “structural excess capacity” Section 301 investigation.
Canada
Canada's camp · government: trade minister's statement, 23 July 2026; French-language press
Ottawa says the tariff has no basis but was expected. The minister, Dominic LeBlanc, said the measure was not unexpected because Washington had signalled it would replace its baseline tariffs, noted that goods complying with the North American agreement are exempt, and said Canada has one of the world's most robust frameworks against forced labour. In a submission reported by Le Devoir, the government argued there is no foundation for the duty and asked to be assessed separately. The prime minister, Mark Carney, said he supported the overall aim and promised a bill. Radio-Canada describes the approach as a way round the limits the Supreme Court set.64 65 66
Then the two governments traded tariffs. After a near-final deal collapsed on 21 August 2026, Washington imposed 50% on about $20 billion of Canadian goods and Ottawa replied on C$27.6 billion of American goods. The finance minister called the American terms “économiquement intenables, injustes et, en fin de compte, inacceptables” (economically untenable, unjust and, in the end, unacceptable). Talks resumed on 31 October.101 102 103
Brazil
Brazil's camp · press reporting the vice-president and government · source in Portuguese
Brasília calls its 25% unjust and goes to the WTO. Brazilian reports say the tariff followed a Section 301 investigation and took effect on 22 July 2026. Geraldo Alckmin called it “injusta e descabida” (unjust and uncalled for), pointing out that the United States runs a trade surplus with Brazil, and said President Lula's instruction was to keep negotiating while diversifying export markets. Brazil filed a complaint at the World Trade Organization and is pressing a Mercosur trade deal with South Korea. Consultations ended without agreement and a panel request is due on 24 November.69 70 106
India
India's camp · press reporting the commerce ministry · source in Hindi
New Delhi stays in talks. Hindi-language reports say India was placed in the 10% tier, below the 12.5% first proposed. The commerce ministry says it is in contact with Washington on the Section 301 proceedings and refers to the trade-agreement framework announced on 2 February 2026. Indian trade experts quoted in the same press urged a firmer legal response and warned of damage to textiles, garments, carpets, leather and gems.71 72
Indonesia
Indonesia's camp · press reporting the coordinating economy minister
Jakarta counts on exclusions. Indonesian goods pay 10% under the July action. The minister, Airlangga Hartarto, expects a final rate of about 18% after all components and agreed exclusions, and says the Trade Representative plans to grant 18 exclusion requests. The source read is the English edition of an Indonesian outlet.73
Where the camps disagree
- Whether there is a ceiling. China says the US promised no more than 20% in replacement tariffs; South Korea says it has a reconfirmed 15% cap. Washington has published neither commitment in those words.48 55
- What the tariffs are for. Washington says forced labour. Beijing, Tokyo, Hanoi, Ottawa and Brussels each say the finding does not describe them, and Beijing calls the purpose protectionist. Taipei alone presents its rate as recognition.3 48 53 57 64 68 62
- How to respond. Brazil has gone to the World Trade Organization. China reserves countermeasures. Vietnam, India, Indonesia, Mexico and Canada have chosen talks and exclusions.70 48 57 72 73 59 64
- What the Supreme Court changed. American lawyers see a constitutional limit on the presidency. Chinese commentators see a change of legal label with a modest fall in rates.2 50 51