The law and the courts
How the Supreme Court removed the tariffs of 2025, what the administration put in their place, and what happened to the money already paid.
The ruling
On 20 February 2026 the Supreme Court held, by six votes to three, that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act does not authorise the president to impose tariffs. The cases had been brought by importers and by states against the “fentanyl” and “reciprocal” tariffs of 2025. Collection of those duties ended on 24 February.2 33
The Court did not say whether importers were owed their money back, or how. It left tariffs under other statutes untouched: the Section 301 tariffs on China from 2018 onwards and every Section 232 sector tariff continued to apply throughout.2
What replaced the struck-down tariffs
- 24 February 2026: a 10% surcharge under Section 122. The statute allows up to 15% for at most 150 days unless Congress extends it. An order for 15% was announced; 10% was what was collected.1 2
- 7 May 2026: a setback in the trade court. The Court of International Trade ruled 2–1 that the legal conditions for the surcharge had not been met, but limited relief to three named importers. An appellate order on 11 June let collection continue.2
- 12 March 2026: two Section 301 investigations opened, one on forced labour covering 60 economies and one on structural excess capacity covering 16.28 27
- 24 July 2026: the forced-labour tariffs took effect as the surcharge expired, at 10% or 12.5%.3
- Since then: the forced-labour tariffs are under challenge at the Court of International Trade. Sources read for this site disagree on whether the court has yet ruled, so the status is given here as pending. The Congressional Research Service notes that some commentators think the breadth of the authority claimed raises the same “major questions” concern that sank the emergency tariffs.2 27
Refunds
About $166 billion in emergency-powers duties had been collected. US Customs has run a refund process since 20 April 2026. Refunds are not automatic; importers must apply. About $126 billion, including interest, had been paid by 2 October 2026, and the monthly flow has slowed sharply since June.98 100 17 2
What is left depends on an appeal. The trade court ordered refunds for every importer, including those that never sued. The government appealed on 3 June; a class of importers was certified on 8 October; and the last brief in the appeal was filed on 9 November, so it is ready to be decided. Customs reported about $137.9 billion in potential and certified refunds on file by 23 October.98 99
Who ends up with the money is a separate question. The importer of record gets the refund. Whether it passes any of it to the customers who paid higher prices depends on contracts, and no rule requires it.
Show these figures as a table
| Item | Amount | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Collected under emergency powers | $166 billion | before 24 February 2026 |
| Refunded by 2 October 2026 | $126 billion | including interest; the process opened on 20 April 2026 |
Sources: US Customs reports to the trade court, as reported in Korean, Japanese and US legal press.98 100 99 17
Why the ruling did not end the trade war
The decision was about which law the president may use, not about whether tariffs may be imposed. Three other statutes were available, and within five months a general tariff was back in place on nearly every trading partner. What changed is the shape: rates are flatter and lower, they rest on investigations that take months, and they can be challenged on their own terms. For China, the removal of 20 points of emergency tariffs was followed by 12.5 points under Section 301.1 3