Trade War

Helms-Burton Title III: Supreme Court revives cruise-line case, denies CIMEX immunity to Exxon

Two 2026 rulings widened lawsuits over property Cuba confiscated after 1959. Cruise lines face a revived claim over Havana's docks, and Cuban state firms such as CIMEX cannot claim sovereign immunity in such suits. Both cases are back in lower courts.

The law 18 November 2026

The US Supreme Court decided two cases in 2026 under Title III of the Helms-Burton Act, the 1996 law that lets US owners of property confiscated by Cuba after 1 January 1959 sue anyone who "traffics" in it. On 21 May it revived a claim against four cruise lines over their use of Havana's docks, and on 23 June it ruled that Cuban state companies cannot claim sovereign immunity in such suits. Both cases were sent back to lower courts.1 2

What Title III is

The Cuban Liberty and Democratic Solidarity Act, known as Helms-Burton, gives US nationals a right to sue over confiscated property. The president may suspend that right. Presidents Clinton, Bush and Obama kept it suspended from the start, and President Donald Trump let the suspension lapse in May 2019, the Court's syllabus records.1

The state news agency Prensa Latina describes the claims as rooted in a unilateral embargo and the takings as sovereign nationalisations. That is Havana's position.3 4

The cruise-line case

Havana Docks Corporation, a US company, held a concession to build and run docks in the Port of Havana. It was due to expire in 2004. Cuba seized the docks in 1960, and the US Foreign Claims Settlement Commission certified about US$9 million in losses plus 6% annual interest.1

From 2016 to 2019, Royal Caribbean, Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings, Carnival and MSC Cruises carried nearly a million paying passengers to Cuba through those docks. A Florida federal court found all four liable and awarded Havana Docks more than US$100 million from each. Prensa Latina puts the 2022 judgment at US$439 million plus fees. An appeals court reversed it, holding that because the concession would have ended in 2004, use of the docks from 2016 was not trafficking.1 3

The Supreme Court disagreed by eight votes to one. Writing for the Court, Justice Clarence Thomas held that the confiscated property can be the docks themselves, not only the time-limited concession, so the cruise lines' use of them was enough.1

"...anyone who uses the property can be liable to those who had an interest in the tainted property."1

Justice Elena Kagan dissented, arguing that the docks had belonged to the Cuban government all along and that Havana Docks owned only an interest that expired in 2004. The Court did not rule on the cruise lines' other defences, which return to the appeals court.1

The Exxon case

Exxon Mobil sued two Cuban state companies, the fuel group Unión Cuba-Petróleo (CUPET) and the CIMEX corporation, and later a Panamanian company it calls CIMEX's alter ego, over a refinery, terminals and more than a hundred service stations taken in 1960. It seeks more than US$1 billion. Lower courts dismissed the case under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, which shields foreign states and their agencies unless an exception applies.2

By six votes to three, the Court held that Helms-Burton itself removes that immunity for Cuban agencies and instrumentalities. Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote that the law names agencies and instrumentalities among those who can be sued, and that the immunity act's exceptions could almost never be met for Cuban defendants because the embargo bars most commerce with the United States. Justice Kagan, joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson, dissented, saying the bar for removing immunity is high and the law falls short of it.2

In both cases the Trump administration argued as a friend of the court for the plaintiffs.1 2

La Corte Suprema de Estados Unidos allanó hoy el camino de posibles demandas contra Cuba

The US Supreme Court today cleared the way for possible lawsuits against Cuba3

That was Prensa Latina's account of the May ruling. When the cases were argued in February, the agency reported protesters outside the Court who called Exxon's suit legal warfare.3 4

What it changes

The Exxon ruling opens US courts to Helms-Burton claims against Cuban state firms such as CIMEX, which is also on the State Department's Cuba Restricted List. Under the Havana Docks ruling, a company that used confiscated physical assets can face a claim even where the claimant's own interest would have run out, subject to its other defences.1 2 5

Neither ruling sets damages. What the lower courts decide on remand, including any amounts, had not been confirmed in the sources read for this article.1 2

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of the United States. Havana Docks Corp. v. Royal Caribbean Cruises, Ltd., No. 24-983, 608 U.S. 235. 21 May 2026United States' camp · court ruling
  2. Supreme Court of the United States. Exxon Mobil Corp. v. Corporación Cimex, S. A. (Cuba), No. 24-699, 609 U.S. 108. 23 June 2026United States' camp · court ruling
  3. Prensa Latina. Corte Suprema de EEUU allana demandas contra Cuba con la Helms-Burton (US Supreme Court clears way for suits against Cuba under Helms-Burton). 21 May 2026Cuba's camp · state media · in Spanish
  4. Prensa Latina. Cuba, una prueba en Corte Suprema de EEUU (Cuba, a test at the US Supreme Court). 23 February 2026Cuba's camp · state media · in Spanish
  5. US Department of State. Cuba Restricted List: List of Restricted Entities and Subentities Associated with Cuba as of July 14, 2025. 14 July 2025United States' camp · government

All articles