Trade War

WTO sets up a panel on the EU's carbon border levy at Russia's request

WTO members set up a panel on 25 September to examine the EU's carbon border adjustment mechanism after Russia asked twice. The EU says it will defend the levy but deal only with the panel. Russia's economy minister says over 20 members have joined.

The law 17 November 2026

The World Trade Organization's Dispute Settlement Body agreed on 25 September 2026 to set up a panel that will examine whether the European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) and part of its emissions trading scheme comply with WTO rules. The request came from Russia. It was Russia's second request: the EU objected to the first on 24 July and the body deferred the matter.1 2 3

Russia's economy minister, Maxim Reshetnikov, returned to the case in an interview with the Russian news agency Interfax published on 9 November, saying that the dispute had drawn unusual attention from other members.4

What the levy is and what Russia claims

CBAM requires importers of certain goods into the EU to buy and surrender certificates matching the carbon emissions embedded in those goods. The European Commission says it has applied in its definitive form since 1 January 2026 and covers cement, iron and steel, aluminium, fertilisers, electricity and hydrogen. The Commission describes it as a way of ensuring that the price of imports reflects their embedded carbon emissions.5

Russia asked for consultations, the first stage of a WTO complaint, on 12 May 2025. According to the WTO's summary of the dispute, numbered DS639, Russia claims the CBAM package breaches several articles of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, among them the rules on most-favoured-nation treatment, bound tariff rates, national treatment and quantitative restrictions, as well as the Import Licensing Agreement. Russia also cites the accession protocols of Bulgaria, Latvia, Estonia, Croatia and Lithuania.2 4

The second limb of the complaint concerns the EU Emissions Trading System. Russia says that free emission allowances handed to certain industries amount to an export subsidy prohibited by the WTO's subsidies agreement. RAPSI, a Russian legal news agency, reported, citing a WTO press release, that Russia's argument is that inclusion on the list of sectors at risk of carbon leakage depends on how much a sector trades with countries outside the EU.2 6

At the July meeting Russia said it supports environmental protection but considers the EU measures overly restrictive and discriminatory and aimed at protecting EU industries, according to the WTO's account.3

The EU's answer: it will take part, but not talk to Russia

The EU refused consultations on 22 May 2025, saying they could not be fruitful. In July it told the Dispute Settlement Body that it had declined because of what it called "Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine", and assured members that CBAM was designed in a non-discriminatory and even-handed manner.2 3

In a communication of 22 September 2026 the EU said that if a panel were set up it would take part only as far as needed to defend its measures, and would engage with the panel and not directly with Russia. It added that taking part should not be read as accepting that Russia's actions, including this request, are legitimate. At the September meeting the EU said it would participate to reaffirm its support for the rules-based trading system and expressed confidence that both CBAM and the emissions trading scheme are consistent with WTO rules.1 2

Who else has joined

The WTO's dispute page lists 28 members that reserved their rights to take part in the proceedings as third parties. They include the United States, China, India, Brazil, Japan, Korea, the United Kingdom, Canada, Türkiye, South Africa and Saudi Arabia. The WTO's news summary issued after the meeting named 18 of them.1 2

Mr Reshetnikov pointed to that interest in his interview.4

К нашему спору присоединились более 20 стран, включая Бразилию, Индию, США, Японию.

More than 20 countries have joined our dispute, including Brazil, India, the United States and Japan.4

He compared the level of interest to the dispute over the US steel and aluminium tariffs of 2018. The WTO page records only that the rights were reserved, not what any of these members will argue. Interfax also reported the ministry's earlier statement that, despite EU sanctions, CBAM affects Russian producers, including in third-country markets, because it covers the whole production chain of the goods concerned.2 4

What is still open

The WTO's dispute page, as read on 17 November, records the establishment of the panel and nothing after it: no panelists are named and no report date is given.2

At the same September meeting, according to the WTO's account, a proposal by 130 members to start filling the vacancies on the WTO's Appellate Body was put forward for the 100th time and the United States said it did not support it.1

Sources

  1. World Trade Organization. Panel to review EU carbon border adjustment mechanism and emissions trading scheme. 25 September 2026Independent camp · international body
  2. World Trade Organization. DS639: European Union and its Member States - Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism. read 17 November 2026Independent camp · international body
  3. World Trade Organization. Russia requests dispute panel on EU carbon border adjustment and emissions trading scheme. 24 July 2026Independent camp · international body
  4. Interfax. Решетников сообщил об интересе участников ВТО к спору России с ЕС об углеродном регулировании [Reshetnikov reports WTO members' interest in Russia's dispute with the EU over carbon regulation]. 9 November 2026Russia's camp · press interviewing the minister · in Russian
  5. European Commission, Taxation and Customs Union. Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism. read 17 November 2026European Union's camp · government
  6. RAPSI (Russian Legal Information Agency). Россия оспорила в ВТО пошлину ЕС на углеродный след продукции [Russia challenges the EU's levy on the carbon footprint of goods at the WTO]. 28 July 2026Russia's camp · state media · in Russian

All articles