Trade War

Western Sahara phosphate shipments rise as the remaining buyers defend their sourcing

An advocacy group's shipment count puts India, Mexico and New Zealand at the centre of Western Sahara's phosphate trade. New Zealand suppliers defend their checks while campaigners dispute consent.

Other countries 17 November 2026

Western Sahara exported more phosphate rock to fewer destinations in 2025, according to a shipment survey published by Western Sahara Resource Watch on 29 May 2026. The group, which campaigns for Sahrawi self-determination, counted about 2.02 million tonnes aboard 36 vessels, against 1.45 million tonnes the previous year. Its figures are a monitoring estimate, rather than a customs release.1

India accounts for most of the recorded cargo

The survey identified India as the destination for 1.34 million tonnes, followed by Mexico with 508,000 tonnes and New Zealand with 171,000 tonnes. It reported only three importing companies across those destinations. These are shipments of phosphate rock for fertiliser production, rather than a measure of finished fertiliser sold by those countries.1

WSRW calls for purchases to stop until the territorial conflict is resolved. It expects processing investment to alter the export product, but its survey records rock shipments rather than future manufactured fertiliser.1

New Zealand buyers cite the rock's properties

The Fertiliser Association of New Zealand gives a different account of continued purchasing. It says Phosboucraa rock suits domestic superphosphate manufacturing because of its phosphorus content and comparatively low cadmium. Its sourcing page identifies Ballance Agri-Nutrients and Ravensdown as members receiving advice on business and human rights. Those names describe the association's due-diligence work, not an additional list of importers for the survey year.2

The association says it commissioned Tuhana Business and Human Rights to assess sourcing and that the consultancy visited Western Sahara in October 2023. The review examined workplace conditions, employee relations and procurement for services at the operation. The trade body acknowledges that further work is needed and says it will seek updates on the use of mine returns and benefits to local communities. These are the buyers' stated safeguards, not an independent resolution of the sovereignty dispute.2

Community benefits and consent remain contested

The European Court of Justice distinguished residents' consultation from the consent of the Sahrawi people when ruling on separate EU-Morocco agricultural and fisheries agreements on 4 October 2024. It held that presumed consent required specific conditions, including a demonstrable benefit proportional to resource exploitation. That judgment concerned those agreements, not an order adjudicating these phosphate shipments.3

The court described the required benefit as:

précis, concret, substantiel et vérifiable

Specific, concrete, substantial and verifiable.3

The UN Secretary-General's report dated 1 October 2026 describes renewed negotiations between Morocco and the Polisario Front, alongside Algeria and Mauritania. It says sovereignty and self-determination remained central disagreements and that proposals under discussion were negotiating documents rather than an agreed settlement. Commercial relationships therefore continue while the underlying political process is unresolved.4

The outstanding question is what further sourcing evidence the buyers publish and whether their promised monitoring changes the terms of continued purchases.2

Sources

  1. Western Sahara Resource Watch. Record low number of importers of Western Sahara phosphates. 29 May 2026Sahrawi self-determination advocates' camp · advocacy shipment tracker
  2. Fertiliser Association of New Zealand. Due Diligence. Accessed 17 November 2026Industry camp · trade association
  3. Court of Justice of the European Union. Sahara occidental : les accords commerciaux UE-Maroc de 2019 en matière de pêche et de produits agricoles, auxquels le peuple du Sahara occidental n’a pas consenti, ont été conclus en méconnaissance des principes de l’autodétermination et de l’effet relatif des traités [Western Sahara: the 2019 EU-Morocco fisheries and agricultural agreements lacked the people's consent and breached self-determination and treaty principles]. 4 October 2024European Union's camp · court press release · in French
  4. United Nations Secretary-General, hosted by Fertiliser Association of New Zealand. Situation concerning Western Sahara: Report of the Secretary-General, S/2026/781. 1 October 2026Independent camp · international organisation report

All articles