Trade War

US court orders German paper maker Koehler to pay $193.6 million in old duties and interest

The US trade court entered default judgment on 18 September against two Koehler companies for anti-dumping duties on receipt paper imported in 2009 to 2011. It refused Washington's request to bar the group's imports until it pays.

The law 17 November 2026

The US Court of International Trade has ordered two companies of the German paper group Koehler to pay $193,631,642.08 in unpaid anti-dumping duties and earlier interest, plus later interest, on thermal paper shipped to the United States between November 2009 and October 2011. In the same opinion, dated 18 September 2026, Judge Gary Katzmann refused the US government's request for an order barring Koehler from importing into the United States until the debt is paid.1 2

The ruling is two months old and this site had not reported it.1

How a receipt-paper case reached $193.6 million

Thermal paper is the heat-sensitive paper used for till, cash-machine and petrol-pump receipts. Anti-dumping duties are extra import duties set by the US Commerce Department under an order covering a product from a named country. The department placed such an order on lightweight thermal paper from Germany in 2008, and the opinion says Koehler's predecessor company, Papierfabrik August Koehler, was subject to it until it was revoked in 2013.1

The court recounts that in a review of that order the Commerce Department determined that the company had engaged in what the department called a "deliberate scheme to conceal home market sales and manipulate home market price data". The department then set a duty rate of 75.36% on Koehler's shipments for the two years from 1 November 2009 to 31 October 2011. The company had paid cash deposits of 3.77% or 6.50% when the goods entered.1

Koehler challenged the rate and lost. The opinion cites two decisions of the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, in 2016 and 2018, upholding it, with the Supreme Court declining to hear either case. After US Customs applied that rate to the entries, the unpaid duties came to $145.3 million. Counting interest up to that point and deducting payments by surety companies, Koehler's liability was $193.6 million when the government sued on 24 January 2024.1

Koehler stopped defending the case

The defendants are Koehler Oberkirch GmbH, the renamed original company, and Koehler Paper SE. The government alleges that Koehler Paper was created with intent to defraud US Customs and received more than three-quarters of Koehler Oberkirch's assets. Because the judgment was entered by default, the court took the well-pleaded allegations in the complaint as true; it did not hold a trial on them.1

After losing a motion to dismiss, Koehler told the government in writing that it "will not participate in any discovery in this case". Discovery is the stage at which the government had sent it written questions to answer. According to the opinion, it suggested the government seek a default judgment instead, said it could not pay the sum claimed, and cited German and European Union law as its reason for not answering. It did not press that foreign-law argument before the judge, who treated it as waived.1

Koehler did not dispute the amount. It maintained its earlier objections that it was not properly served and that the court lacks jurisdiction over Koehler Paper, both of which the court had already rejected.1

The import ban the court would not grant

The government asked the court to bar Koehler and affiliated parties from importing goods into the United States until the judgment is paid, a remedy both sides agreed would be "novel". Its lawyers argued that a money judgment alone was inadequate because Koehler would refuse to pay. Two American thermal paper producers, Domtar and Appvion, filed a brief supporting the government.1

Judge Katzmann refused on a procedural ground. The court's rules say a default judgment may not differ in kind from what the complaint demanded, and the government's complaint asked only for money. He did not decide Koehler's wider objections, including that the court has no power to issue such an injunction at all.1

The judgment makes both companies jointly liable for the $193.6 million plus interest. The government told the court that with interest the total was already more than $275 million on 12 June 2025, and the opinion says it has continued to grow. A footnote records Koehler's acknowledgment that collection procedures exist, including ones involving assets held by affiliated Koehler companies in the United States.1

The German side

No statement by Koehler on the ruling was found for this article. In a statement of 5 April 2025 about US tariffs announced days earlier, the group's finance chief, Frank Lendowski, said: "The US market has traditionally been a major sales market for the Koehler Group, and access to it is important to us." The group said then that its companies make around 480,000 tons of speciality paper a year at five sites in Germany and export more than 70% of it.3

German thermal paper is under an American anti-dumping measure today, one that dates from 2021, after the order at issue in the court case had been revoked. Germany Trade & Invest, the German government's foreign trade agency, reported on 8 October 2026 that the US Commerce Department had begun a five-year review of the duties on thermal paper from Germany, Spain, Japan and South Korea.4

Der Antidumpingzoll auf Thermopapier aus Deutschland basiert auf einer Maßnahme aus dem Jahr 2021 und unterliegt jährlichen Überprüfungen.

The anti-dumping duty on thermal paper from Germany is based on a measure from 2021 and is subject to annual reviews.4

What is not yet known

The court's public list of 2026 opinions, read on 17 November, shows no later opinion in the case. Whether Koehler has appealed and whether any of the sum has been collected could not be established from the documents read.2

Sources

  1. US Court of International Trade. United States v. Koehler Oberkirch GmbH and Koehler Paper SE, Court No. 24-00014, Slip Op. 26-116 (public version). 18 September 2026United States' camp · court ruling
  2. US Court of International Trade. Slip Opinions 2026. read 17 November 2026United States' camp · court record
  3. Koehler Group, via Presseportal. Impacts of the tightening of US trade policy for the Koehler Group. 5 April 2025Industry camp · company statement
  4. Germany Trade & Invest. USA überprüfen Antidumpingzölle auf Thermopapier aus Deutschland [USA reviews anti-dumping duties on thermal paper from Germany]. 8 October 2026Germany's camp · government agency · in German

All articles