Trade War

US case on China's Phase One compliance passes a year with no published finding

Washington opened a Section 301 investigation into China's 2020 trade deal on 24 October 2025 and held a hearing that December. No determination has appeared in the Federal Register entries this site searched. Beijing says it kept the deal.

US and China 17 November 2026

The United States opened an investigation on 24 October 2025 into whether China has kept the trade agreement the two countries signed in January 2020, known as the Phase One Agreement. More than a year later, a search of Federal Register notices from the Office of the US Trade Representative (USTR) on 17 November 2026 returned the notice that opened the case and no later notice announcing a finding or a tariff.1 6 China's Commerce Ministry says China met its commitments and has warned that it will respond if the case produces tariffs.3

What Washington is investigating

The case was opened under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, the law that lets the US Trade Representative investigate a foreign government's practices and then impose tariffs or other restrictions. The notice of initiation says the investigation was begun "at the direction of the President" and asks whether US rights under the Phase One Agreement are being denied.1

The notice sets out the American allegation. It says China "appears not to have lived up to its commitments" on intellectual property, forced technology transfer, agriculture and financial services. On purchases, it says China committed to buy more than $535 billion of US goods and services in calendar years 2020 and 2021 taken together, and that official US export data "appears to show" a shortfall of more than $217 billion. These are allegations in a notice that opens an investigation, not findings.1

USTR asked the public what action to take, including the level and scope of any duties on Chinese goods, fees or restrictions on Chinese services, and import restrictions. Written comments were due by 1 December 2025 and a public hearing was set for 16 December 2025. The notice says the Trade Representative "must determine" whether the conduct is actionable; the text gives no date for that determination.1

In the press release announcing the case, the Trade Representative, Jamieson Greer, said it "underscores the Trump Administration's resolve to hold China to its Phase One Agreement commitments".2

What Beijing says

A Chinese reply on the record came on 25 February 2026, after Mr Greer said the investigation would continue and might lead to tariffs, according to the question put to the ministry as Xinhua, China's state news agency, reported it. A Commerce Ministry spokesperson said China had completed its commitments on intellectual property protection and on opening its financial and farm markets on schedule, and had fully performed on expanding trade despite the pandemic and supply chain disruption.3

The spokesperson turned the charge round, saying US export controls and limits on two-way investment had violated the spirit of the agreement, and referred to a white paper China published on 9 April 2025 for its full account. The statement ended with a warning.3

如果美方执意推进相关调查,甚至以调查为由出台关税等限制性措施,中方将采取一切必要措施,坚决捍卫自身合法权益。

If the US side insists on pushing ahead with the investigation, or even introduces restrictive measures such as tariffs on the grounds of the investigation, China will take all necessary measures to firmly defend its legitimate rights and interests.3

The spokesperson also said the two sides had discussed the Phase One Agreement several times during five rounds of trade talks since 2025, and asked Washington to look ahead with China and concentrate on carrying out what the two sides have already agreed.3

Where the case stands

No determination is in the notices this site found. A search on 17 November 2026 of Federal Register documents from USTR containing the words "Phase One Agreement" returned three entries: a notice from January 2020, the initiation notice of 28 October 2025, and a request for comments of 5 June 2026 on a mechanism for managed trade with China, which describes the agreement as background. That search covers the Federal Register only. It does not cover statements USTR may have made elsewhere.6

The American law firm Covington, in a client note of 10 August 2026, listed the case among Section 301 investigations still pending and said USTR had held its hearing in December 2025. It wrote that a determination and "any resulting responsive trade measures are expected by the fall of 2026". That was the firm's expectation, not an official timetable.4

The Congressional Research Service, which advises the US Congress, recorded the opening of the investigation in a paper updated on 21 May 2026 and put a question to legislators: what actions USTR might take if it determines that China failed to implement provisions of the deal. By the same paper's count, China fulfilled 60% of its goods purchase commitments for 2020 and 2021.5

Why it matters for the truce

The Phase One case is one of several open US proceedings against China that sit beside the tariff truce, which China last extended for two months from 10 November 2026. Covington's note lists it separately from the investigation into "structural excess capacity" in 16 economies, which Washington opened on 11 March 2026.4 7

The two governments describe the same record in opposite terms. Washington's notice speaks of an "apparent failure to comply"; Beijing says it performed and that the United States broke the spirit of the deal. No neutral body has ruled on either claim: the investigation is conducted by USTR itself, and the notice records that USTR requested consultations with the Chinese government.1 3

The open question is whether USTR publishes a determination, and any proposed measures, before that two-month extension runs out in January 2027.7

Sources

  1. Federal Register (Office of the US Trade Representative). Initiation of Section 301 Investigation: China's Implementation of Commitments Under the Phase One Agreement; Notice of Hearing; and Request for Public Comments. 28 October 2025United States' camp · government
  2. Office of the US Trade Representative. USTR Initiates Section 301 Investigation of China's Implementation of the Phase One Agreement. 24 October 2025United States' camp · government
  3. Xinhua (新华网). 商务部:希望美方客观理性看待中美第一阶段经贸协议实施问题 (Commerce Ministry: hopes the US will view implementation of the Phase One agreement objectively and rationally). 25 February 2026China's camp · state media reporting the ministry · in Chinese
  4. Covington & Burling. Current and Forthcoming Section 301 Trade Actions by the Trump Administration. 10 August 2026United States' camp · law firm analysis
  5. Congressional Research Service (via EveryCRSReport). Section 301 and China: The U.S.-China Phase One Trade Deal. 21 May 2026United States' camp · congressional research
  6. Federal Register. Document search: Office of the US Trade Representative, term "Phase One Agreement". 17 November 2026United States' camp · government
  7. Xinhua (新华网). 国务院关税税则委员会发布公告调整对原产于美国的进口商品加征关税措施 (Customs Tariff Commission issues notice adjusting additional tariffs on imports originating in the United States). 9 November 2026China's camp · state media reporting the government · in Chinese

All articles