Trade War

US data-processing safeguards require more than encrypting an overseas transfer

CISA's security conditions govern access during restricted data transactions. Encryption does not remove a contract from the programme, and audits must examine how the controls actually operate.

The law 17 November 2026

Encrypting sensitive American data before an overseas service provider receives it does not by itself take the arrangement outside US national-security controls. The Justice Department's current guidance says safeguards do not change whether a transaction is covered by the Data Security Program. Other compliance obligations continue after technical protections are installed.2

The operational issue is what the recipient can obtain from the protected information. CISA's final explanation permits restricted transactions through outright denial of access or an effective combination of techniques such as encryption, aggregation, pseudonymisation and de-identification. Organisational and system controls must accompany the protections applied to the data.1

A cloud contract needs controls throughout the service

CISA illustrates the boundary with a US customer storing encrypted covered data through a cloud provider headquartered in a country of concern. The transaction can proceed if the customer fully implements the security requirements, including those governing encryption and keys. The example describes a conditional route for storage services, rather than approving any named cloud platform.1

The agency also explains why changing the appearance of information is insufficient: protective techniques can sometimes be reversed or undermined. Its risk assessment must support the conclusion that the implemented measures effectively prevent access to identifiable or otherwise inadequately protected covered data.1

Justice's FAQ identifies a commercial limit. If the only service a provider supplies requires access to the underlying identifiable or decryptable information, implementing the security requirements may prevent that service from being delivered. In that circumstance, the transaction may effectively be prohibited without a specific licence. This is different from a general prohibition on hiring overseas employees or engaging foreign vendors.2

Auditors must test the arrangements

The final regulation requires an annual audit for US persons engaging in restricted transactions. The auditor must be qualified and independent, and cannot be a country of concern or covered person. An internal auditor can qualify if independence is maintained; hiring an outside firm is not the sole permitted method.3

The audit must examine the transactions, compliance programme, records and implementation of security requirements. Its written report includes the methodology, findings and recommendations. Records of the audit must be retained for at least ten years. Those requirements make evidence of operation relevant beyond the initial purchase of a security product.3

Overseas groups must examine their American entities

Japanese law firm Nagashima Ohno & Tsunematsu's March 2025 analysis highlights the need for a programme with procedures proportionate to risk. Its description includes:4

データの流れ

Data flows.4

The analysis explains that those procedures examine data types and volumes, counterparties, ultimate uses and transfer methods. It also notes that Japanese groups' US subsidiaries fall within the definition of US persons. For an international group, the relevant unit is therefore not determined solely by where its headquarters sits. The question for the next service contract is whether the documented flow, operational controls and audit evidence support the work the supplier is actually expected to perform.4

Sources

  1. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency. Notice of Availability of Security Requirements for Restricted Transactions Under Executive Order 14117. 8 January 2025United States' camp · final security requirements explanation
  2. US Department of Justice. Data Security Program: Frequently Asked Questions. 24 September 2025United States' camp · government compliance guidance
  3. US Department of Justice. Preventing Access to U.S. Sensitive Personal Data and Government-Related Data by Countries of Concern or Covered Persons. 8 January 2025United States' camp · final regulation
  4. Nagashima Ohno & Tsunematsu. 懸念国による米国人の機微個人データのアクセス防止に関する最終規則の公表 [Final rule preventing countries of concern from accessing Americans' sensitive personal data]. 24 March 2025Industry camp · Japanese legal analysis · in Japanese

All articles