Trade War

Taiwan's chip-secrets case makes supplier supervision a technology-trade issue

Final prison sentences in a TSMC trade-secret case sit alongside a penalty for Tokyo Electron's Taiwan subsidiary. The judgment examines how equipment suppliers supervise access to customers' confidential technology.

The law 17 November 2026

Taiwan's Supreme Court rejected appeals by former TSMC employees Chen Li-ming and Chen Wei-chieh on 30 July 2026, making their respective ten-year and six-year prison sentences final, according to Central News Agency. The case illustrates how technology-protection legislation reaches information obtained inside an established semiconductor supply relationship.1

Chen Li-ming had moved from TSMC to Tokyo Electron Taiwan, which supplies semiconductor equipment. Prosecutors said he repeatedly sought confidential information from former colleagues to help secure equipment orders. The case involved offences under the National Security Act and other legislation, rather than a dispute simply about an employee changing jobs.1

A supplier's controls were tested

The Intellectual Property and Commercial Court's April judgment acknowledged that Tokyo Electron Taiwan already had information-security arrangements, employee agreements and restrictions on forwarding and copying customer information. Its finding was therefore more specific than an absence of written compliance policies: the organisation had not adequately assessed and controlled the risks arising from the employee's work and customer relationships.2

The judgment recognised that chipmakers and equipment suppliers need technical discussions during equipment development. It also considered the predictable risk when employees become contacts for a former employer and can draw on old relationships to obtain internal information. For suppliers, the legal exposure concerned the way customer knowledge was acquired, even within commercially useful cooperation.2

Tokyo Electron's Japanese statement acknowledged the court's finding about inadequate supervision and promised stronger group information management. It separately said the investigation and judgment had not established organisational involvement or an external leak of confidential information. Those statements concern different questions: the company accepted a supervisory failing while disputing a broader account of coordinated misconduct.3

The company said it took the finding:

厳粛に受け止めており

With the utmost seriousness.3

Compensation accompanies a suspended fine

Tokyo Electron reported a fine of NT$150 million with a three-year suspension, conditional on payments of NT$100 million to the customer and NT$50 million to the government. It said the parties had agreed stronger principles for protecting and sharing confidential information and that the matter would have no effect on its financial results. That last statement is the company's assessment.3

In its analysis, Brain Trust International Law Firm distinguishes collecting ordinary customer information from knowingly or negligently allowing unlawful acquisition. It says internal performance assessments were important in evaluating whether the subsidiary understood the employee's information-gathering activities. The commercial lesson is that performance incentives and supervision can matter alongside signed confidentiality undertakings.4

The firm also identifies cooperation with investigators, settlement and measures against recurrence as reasons for the suspended sentence. It describes the payments as due within one year after the corporate judgment becomes final. That compliance obligation continues beyond the announcement of a prison sentence; the legal analysis does not establish whether those payments have subsequently been completed.4

Sources

  1. Central News Agency / Focus Taiwan. Ex-TSMC employees receive final sentences in trade secret leak case. 30 July 2026Taiwan's camp · state-funded news agency
  2. Intellectual Property and Commercial Court. 智慧財產及商業法院114年度刑國營訴字第2號刑事判決 [Criminal judgment 114, Xing Guo Ying Su, No. 2]. 27 April 2026Taiwan's camp · court judgment · in Chinese
  3. Tokyo Electron. 当社台湾子会社に対する判決について [Judgment concerning our Taiwan subsidiary]. 27 April 2026Industry camp · company statement · in Japanese
  4. Brain Trust International Law Firm. Corporate criminal liability of Tokyo Electron for employee infringing TSMC's trade secrets. 3 May 2026Independent camp · law firm analysis

All articles