Trade War

Shoppers' suits over refunded tariffs go before a US judicial panel on 3 December

US consumers are suing retailers and brands for a share of refunded tariffs. A judicial panel will hear on 3 December whether to merge the cases. Costco, Nintendo and others say they owe shoppers nothing, and no ruling on that was found.

The law 17 November 2026

American shoppers who paid higher prices while the emergency tariffs were in force are suing the companies that are now getting those tariffs back. On 3 December 2026 the US Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, the body that decides whether similar federal lawsuits are gathered before one judge, is due to hear two such requests in New Orleans. The companies oppose a merger and deny that they owe customers anything.1 2

Why consumers are suing

The Supreme Court struck down the tariffs imposed under emergency powers on 20 February 2026, and US Customs opened its refund portal on 20 April. The refund is paid to the importer of record, the company named as importer on the customs entry. That company is not always the one that bore the cost, and neither source read on the process describes any payment to the customers who bought the goods.3 4

The suits say that is a double recovery: the company raised prices to cover the tariff and now collects the same tariff back from the government. They rely on state consumer-protection laws and on unjust enrichment, the doctrine that a party should not keep a benefit obtained at another's expense. A suit against Costco filed in Illinois on 11 March 2026 asks for a class of everyone who bought a tariffed product there between 1 February 2025 and 24 February 2026.5

What goes to the panel

The panel has already acted once. On 2 October it ordered six suits against Amazon to be combined in the federal court for the Western District of Washington, Bloomberg Law reported.6

The larger request is still open. Customers who sued Amazon and Target asked the panel to gather cases against many retailers in the Northern District of Illinois. CFO Dive reported in September that the request covered at least 25 suits; a case tracker puts it at 25 suits against 15 retailers, and the panel's schedule, on this site's count, lists 24.1 2 5

The panel's notice for its 3 December session lists two tariff matters for oral argument: Retailer Tariff Litigation, a request to send suits against many companies to the Northern District of Illinois, and Target Tariff Litigation, a separate request to send seven suits against Target to the Southern District of New York. The schedule for the larger request names companies including Amazon, Costco, Target, Walmart, Adidas America, Nike, Microsoft and Sony Interactive Entertainment. The suit against Nintendo is not on it.1

The companies say each case is different, and that nothing is owed

More than a dozen companies opposed the request in September. Twelve of them filed jointly, among them Adidas America, Costco, Walmart, Microsoft, Sony Interactive Entertainment, Puma's US units, Shein and Canon USA. According to CFO Dive's account of the filing, they argue that each importer made its own pricing decisions for its own reasons, so the cases share too little to be tried together, and that joint evidence-gathering would expose confidential pricing data. Amazon and Costco filed separate oppositions.2

Costco has said it will pass refunds on through lower prices. The Illinois plaintiff answers that cheaper goods for future shoppers do not repay past ones. Costco asked the court to dismiss the case on 18 May, saying among other things that it had not yet received refunds; in August it told the court it had received about a third of what it expected. The tracker found no ruling on the docket up to 30 September.2 5

Nintendo of America is the clearest statement of the defence. Two customers sued it in the federal court for the Western District of Washington in April. In a motion to dismiss filed on 20 July, Nintendo argued that buyers got the product they agreed to pay for, that it charged a single price in which no tariff can be isolated, and that it has no legal duty to hand on a refund. It also asked for one plaintiff's claim to be sent to arbitration.7 8 9

The Japanese trade site GameBusiness.jp put the filing's argument this way in Japanese; the English below is this site's translation of the Japanese, not the wording of Nintendo's filing:

関税に関連する法的状況が変わったからといって、原告らがリベートを受ける権利はない

A change in the legal situation surrounding tariffs does not give the plaintiffs a right to a rebate.8

The complaint, as reported by the US outlet Aftermath and relayed by the same site in April, called the refund a windfall for a company that had already recovered the cost from consumers through higher prices.9

No ruling found on who is right

The sources read for this article report no ruling on a motion to dismiss. Lawyers at the US firm Snell & Wilmer reported on 27 July that the court had ruled on neither of Nintendo's motions, and the case tracker showed no ruling in the Illinois Costco case as of 30 September. The other suits' dockets were not checked.5 7

The question has also reached Washington. Seven Democratic senators wrote to the chairman of the Federal Trade Commission on 11 November asking whether large companies that received refunds acted deceptively in not offering refunds to consumers, according to Inside U.S. Trade. No reply is mentioned in that report.10

Contracts settle the matter between businesses: an exporter or a wholesale buyer gets a share of a refund if its supply contract says so. The consumer suits rest instead on state consumer-protection law and unjust enrichment.4 5

The panel hears argument on 3 December. Whether the cases are merged or stay apart, the motions to dismiss remain to be decided by the judges who hold them.1 5

Sources

  1. US Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation. Notice of Hearing Session, 3 December 2026, New Orleans (hearing session order filed 9 October 2026). 9 October 2026United States' camp · court notice
  2. CFO Dive. Amazon, Costco among companies fighting centralized tariff refund suits. 18 September 2026United States' camp · press
  3. The Fashion Law. Who Gets the Refund? Brands & Consumers Collide Over Tariffs Windfall (first published 20 March 2026, updated). 20 April 2026Independent camp · legal press
  4. Law Times (법률신문), article by the law firm Yulchon. IEEPA 관세 환급, 수입자가 받고 끝나는가 - 공급계약의 관세 부담 조항을 다시 보아야 하는 이유 [IEEPA tariff refunds: does it end with the importer being paid? Why tariff clauses in supply contracts need another look]. 22 October 2026South Korea's camp · law firm analysis · in Korean
  5. Open Class Actions. Costco Tariff Refund Class Action Lawsuit. 2 November 2026Independent camp · tracker
  6. Bloomberg Law. Amazon Tariff Refund Suits Combined in Washington Federal Court. 5 October 2026United States' camp · press
  7. Snell & Wilmer. Game Over? What Nintendo's Motion to Dismiss Means for Importers Facing Class Actions for Tariff Refunds. 27 July 2026Independent camp · law firm analysis
  8. GameBusiness.jp. 任天堂「米国において関税払い戻しを消費者に還元する法的義務はない」―消費者は合意通りのものを受け取った [Nintendo: no legal duty in the US to pass tariff refunds on to consumers; consumers received what was agreed]. 23 July 2026Japan's camp · press · in Japanese
  9. GameBusiness.jp. 違憲判決が下った「トランプ関税」を巡り、米国ゲーマー2名が任天堂を提訴。関税のタイミングで値上げした上、「払い戻し」まで受けるのは二重取りとして [Two US gamers sue Nintendo over the struck-down Trump tariffs, calling a price rise plus a refund a double recovery]. 23 April 2026Japan's camp · press · in Japanese
  10. Inside U.S. Trade. Senate Democrats urge FTC to probe companies that received tariff refunds (headline and summary on the Court of International Trade topic page). 11 November 2026Independent camp · trade press

All articles