Trade War

In its reply brief on the 10% surcharge, Washington says states that paid no tariff cannot sue

The US government's reply brief in the Section 122 appeal defends the expired 10% surcharge and says 23 states have no right to challenge it. The states put their extra costs at about $748 million a year. No hearing date has been published.

The law 17 November 2026

The US government has filed its response and reply brief in the appeal over the 10% surcharge that was charged on nearly all imports from February to July 2026. The brief, which was due on 12 November 2026, asks the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit to reverse the ruling that found the surcharge unlawful. It also argues that 23 of the 24 states that sued had no right to do so, because they paid no tariff themselves.1 3

What is being appealed

Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974 lets a president impose a temporary surcharge to deal with balance-of-payments deficits. On 7 May 2026 the Court of International Trade, the federal court that hears customs cases, held that the president's proclamation had not identified a deficit of the kind the law means. It ordered relief for two importers, Burlap and Barrel and Basic Fun, and for the state of Washington, whose public university imports goods directly. The other states were dismissed for lack of standing, the rule that a plaintiff must show a concrete injury of its own.1 2 4

Japan's trade promotion agency, JETRO, summarised that part of the ruling for Japanese companies:

実際に関税を支払っておらず、間接的な影響しか主張していないことから、原告となる「適格性」が欠如しているとして棄却した

The claims were dismissed for lack of "standing" as plaintiffs, because the states had not actually paid the tariff and asserted only indirect effects.4

The government appealed the ruling on the surcharge. The 23 dismissed states, led by Oregon, appealed their dismissal. The appeals court joined the cases and on 11 June 2026 put the trade court's order on hold while it decides.2 5

The government's case on the surcharge

The brief is signed by the Justice Department's appellate staff. Its main argument is that "balance-of-payments deficit" is a technical term, that economists measured it in several ways when the law was written, and that the president may use any of them that is economically reasonable, including the current-account deficit.1

The challengers read the term as a deficit that puts a country's reserves at risk under fixed exchange rates, the system the United States left in the early 1970s. The government answers that this reading would have made the law useless from the day it passed. In the brief's words, it "would mean that Section 122 has been a dead letter since its enactment".1 2

The dispute over the states

The second half of the brief says a buyer of imported goods cannot challenge a tariff; only the importer who pays it can. The government cites earlier Federal Circuit decisions to that effect and a trade court ruling of 2025 that dismissed a consumer's case. It says the states claim only "downstream economic consequences" that depend on the choices of other companies.1

It also disputes that tariffs are passed on at all:

Whether importers do so is a hotly contested subject in economics.1

The states' brief, filed on 31 August 2026, takes the opposite view. It relies on an economist, Professor Hines, who told the trade court that recent experience shows tariffs raise costs to the final customer "on close to a one-to-one basis". Using federal data on state government spending, he calculated that the plaintiff states buy about $37.4 billion of imports a year and that a 10% surcharge would add about $748 million a year to their direct purchasing costs. The states say the government offered no evidence against those figures. They add that vendors raised prices and reopened contracts under the earlier emergency-powers tariffs, and that one declaration identified more than $1.2 million in tariff surcharges on recent and expected purchases.2

The states ask the appeals court to uphold the ruling against the surcharge, reverse their dismissal and send the case back to the trade court "to fashion appropriate relief for all parties".2

Why standing matters after the surcharge has ended

The surcharge is no longer collected, so the practical question in the appeal is money already paid. The trade court limited its order to the three plaintiffs it found had standing. If the 23 states are let back in, the trade court would have to decide what relief, if any, is due to plaintiffs that bought goods on which someone else paid the duty. The government tells the appeals court it need not reach that question at all if it agrees that the surcharge was lawful.1 2 4

Timetable

The government's brief was first due on 13 October 2026. Its lawyers asked for 30 more days, the challengers did not object, and the appeals court granted the extension on 14 September, moving the deadline to 12 November. The copy of the brief on the public docket is numbered document 107 and carries no filing stamp, so this site cannot confirm the exact day it was filed.1 3 5

None of the court documents read for this article sets a date for oral argument. The open questions are when the court will hear the case and whether it will rule on the states' standing or decide the appeal on the meaning of Section 122 alone.1 3

Sources

  1. US Department of Justice, filed in the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Response and Reply Brief for Appellants, Oregon v. Trump, Nos. 2026-1804, -1805, -1928 (docket document 107). November 2026United States' camp · court filing
  2. Oregon Department of Justice and 23 other states, filed in the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Answering brief of state appellees and cross-appellants, Oregon v. Trump (docket document 77). 31 August 2026Plaintiffs' camp · court filing
  3. US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Order granting the government's unopposed motion to extend the time to file its response and reply brief, Oregon v. Trump (docket document 99). 14 September 2026Independent camp · court order
  4. JETRO (Japan External Trade Organization). 米国際貿易裁判所、122条関税に違法判決、ただし関税を巡る不確実性は続く [US Court of International Trade rules Section 122 tariffs unlawful, but uncertainty over tariffs continues]. 11 May 2026Japan's camp · government trade agency · in Japanese
  5. US Department of Justice, filed in the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Corrected unopposed motion for an extension of time, Oregon v. Trump (docket document 96). September 2026United States' camp · court filing

All articles