Trade War

India's New Zealand trade deal leaves core dairy out, with a right to negotiate

India kept core dairy outside its New Zealand trade deal. Wellington points to duty-free re-export ingredients and a right to negotiate; Fonterra and Labour call the dairy result disappointing.

Other countries 18 November 2026

India kept dairy outside the market access commitments in its free trade agreement with New Zealand, signed on 27 April 2026.1 2 New Zealand's government says the text still contains dairy provisions, including a right to negotiate if India later gives better access to comparable countries. Fonterra, New Zealand's largest dairy exporter, and the opposition Labour Party both called the dairy outcome disappointing.3 4 5

What the two governments say about dairy

India's state broadcaster, reporting the signing in Hindi, lists the protection of India's core interests in dairy, agriculture, and gems and jewellery among the outcomes it presents to Indian listeners.1

डेयरी, कृषि और रत्न एवं आभूषण जैसे क्षेत्रों में भारत के मूल हितों की सुरक्षा।

Protection of India's core interests in sectors such as dairy, agriculture, and gems and jewellery.1

That wording is a summary by the broadcaster of India's presentation, not a quotation from the treaty. Reuters reports that India excluded dairy, coffee, sugar, spices, edible oils and rubber from its commitments.2

New Zealand's trade minister Todd McClay announced the concluded deal on 22 December 2025. His release lists what dairy does receive:3

Reuters, reporting the April signing, gives the same outline: dairy and food ingredients for re-export enter duty-free at once, and bulk infant formula and some high-value dairy products phase in over seven years.2

Industry and opposition reaction

Fonterra's statement of 22 December 2025, attributed to its global external affairs director Simon Tucker, said the talks were "unable to secure any significant new core dairy access opportunities". It called this disappointing but unsurprising given India's long-standing sensitivity about its dairy market. It also thanked McClay and his team for their advocacy and said it would work with the government on the dairy-relevant provisions.4

Labour's trade spokesperson Damien O'Connor said on 23 December 2025 that it was "disappointing that dairy, our biggest export, has been largely left out of this deal". He argued such agreements "cannot be rushed" and said Labour would set its position as a caucus in the new year.5 Labour is the main opposition party, so this is a political position, not a finding about the text.

A trade-press report published on 8 January 2026 adds a practical caution. It quotes Kimberly Crewther, executive director of the Dairy Companies Association of New Zealand, saying "bureaucratic red tape has limited practical use of existing tariff reductions" on dairy destined for re-export.6 The same report notes the better-access pledge and the one-year review.6

How the camps differ

The two governments agree on the central fact: core dairy access was not opened. They differ in emphasis. India presents the exclusion as protection of domestic farmers.1 New Zealand's government presents the deal as having secured narrower dairy gains plus a mechanism to seek more.3 Fonterra's own judgement is that the new access is not significant.4

This article has not read the treaty text, so it cannot say how the right to negotiate is worded, whether it binds India to any outcome, or how "comparable countries" is defined. The release says only that it triggers consultation.3

What to watch

The one-year review runs from the date the agreement enters into force, and no entry-into-force date was found in the sources opened. Until then, the right to negotiate cannot be tested against any Indian offer to another dairy exporter.

Sources

  1. All India Radio (newsonair.gov.in). भारत और न्यूजीलैंड मुक्त व्यापार समझौते पर हस्ताक्षर करेंगे (India and New Zealand sign free trade agreement). 27 April 2026India's camp · state media · in Hindi
  2. Khaleej Times (Reuters report). India-New Zealand trade pact cuts fruit tariffs, boosts exports, visas. 27 April 2026Independent camp · press reporting a wire service
  3. National Party of New Zealand. Hon Todd McClay: New Zealand secures landmark Free Trade Agreement with India. 22 December 2025New Zealand's camp · government
  4. Fonterra. Fonterra acknowledges the outcome of the NZ-India FTA. 22 December 2025Industry camp · company
  5. Labour Party of New Zealand. Lack of dairy gains in India FTA disappointing. 23 December 2025New Zealand's camp · opposition party
  6. eDairy News. India FTA leaves NZ dairy without major market access. 8 January 2026Independent camp · trade press

All articles