Trade War

China bars help with EU evidence-gathering in Nuctech case; EU clears JD.com deal on conditions

The Commission approved JD.com's purchase of the German retailer Ceconomy on 3 November 2026 under its foreign subsidies law, with ten-year conditions. China's Commerce Ministry said in May that no one may carry out or assist EU evidence-gathering on Nuctech.

The law 18 November 2026

The European Commission approved on 3 November 2026 the purchase of Ceconomy, the German owner of the MediaMarkt and Saturn electronics shops, by the Chinese online retailer JD.com, on conditions that last ten years. It acted under the Foreign Subsidies Regulation, an EU law that lets it examine state support that companies receive from governments outside the EU. Beijing has answered the same law with one of its own: China's Commerce Ministry says the Justice Ministry announced on 15 May 2026 a finding that EU evidence-gathering in another case, against the scanner maker Nuctech, is an "improper extraterritorial jurisdiction measure" that no one may carry out.1 2

The regulation is EU law, applied by the Commission. NATO makes no trade law and has no part in it; the alliance is mentioned because, by this site's count from NATO's member list, 23 of the 27 EU states are among its 32 members.1 7

What the regulation allows

The regulation has applied since July 2023. Companies must notify a merger to the Commission when at least one of the merging companies, or the company being bought, is established in the EU with EU turnover of at least €500 million and the parties received at least €50 million in financial contributions from non-EU governments in the three preceding years. After an in-depth investigation the Commission may accept commitments, prohibit the deal or raise no objection.1

The Commission may also open cases on its own initiative and carry out unannounced inspections. A company that refuses an inspection or supplies incomplete records can be fined up to 1% of its turnover in the preceding business year.4

The JD.com decision

JD.com notified the deal on 17 April 2026 and the Commission opened an in-depth investigation on 28 May.6

The Commission found that JD.com received preferential financing, tax incentives and grants from China that are liable to distort the EU market. It said these subsidies contributed to logistics and technology capabilities that Ceconomy would receive after the takeover, and could allow aggressive pricing.1

The companies offered three commitments: to conduct dealings between JD.com and Ceconomy, including financing, on market terms; to offer JD.com's warehousing and logistics to other retailers on the same terms as to Ceconomy; and to do the same with its technology services. An independent trustee will monitor compliance.1

The Nuctech case and China's ruling

The Commission describes Nuctech as a maker of security scanners for airports, ports and border crossings and as part of a group indirectly controlled by the Chinese state. The Commission began the case on its own initiative in April 2024 with inspections at the company's premises in Poland and the Netherlands, and opened an in-depth investigation on 11 December 2025 into grants, tax measures and loans that it says may be subsidies; it has made no final finding in the releases read.3

China's Commerce Ministry gave Beijing's account on 16 May 2026. It says the EU has widened its investigations, forced Chinese banks to cooperate and demanded large amounts of information held in China that is unrelated to the cases. It says the ministry had already found in January 2025 that the EU's practice under the regulation was a trade and investment barrier. It then describes the new step, taken under China's Regulations on Countering Foreign Improper Extraterritorial Jurisdiction:2

认定欧方在对同方威视的FSR调查中,对有关中国实体采取的相关跨境调查做法构成不当域外管辖措施,要求任何组织、个人不得执行或者协助执行该措施。

[The ministries] determined that the cross-border investigative practices the EU side applied to the Chinese entities concerned in its FSR investigation of Nuctech constitute an improper extraterritorial jurisdiction measure, and required that no organisation or individual carry out or assist in carrying out that measure.2

The excerpt is the Commerce Ministry's summary. The Justice Ministry's own announcement was not read for this article, and no Commission reply to it was found in the Commission releases read.2

A second dispute over evidence: Temu

On 31 July 2026 the Commission sent a statement of grounds to PDD Holdings, the owner of the shopping platform Temu, and its Irish subsidiary. The Commission's preliminary view is that Temu failed to cooperate with an unannounced inspection in Dublin between 2 and 5 December 2025, including by not providing information on its IT systems and records. Temu may reply. The main investigation into possible subsidies continues separately.4

What is pending

The Commission's first review of the regulation, published on 14 July 2026, found it fit for purpose and listed two in-depth cases opened on its own initiative, one on threat detection systems and one in the wind sector. Neither had been closed in the releases read for this article. The Commission said it would publish draft procedural changes in the autumn and adopt them in 2027.5

The Chinese Commerce Ministry's list of spokesperson statements, as scanned by this site on 18 November 2026 (the list is not among the sources below), shows no statement on the JD.com decision. The open questions are how Chinese banks and companies asked for evidence by Brussels respond if the May finding still stands (no later source on it was read), and whether the Commission fines Temu.2 4

Sources

  1. European Commission. Commission conditionally approves JD.com's acquisition of CECONOMY under the Foreign Subsidies Regulation. 3 November 2026European Union's camp · government
  2. Ministry of Commerce of China. 商务部新闻发言人就认定欧盟外国补贴调查相关做法构成不当域外管辖措施答记者问 [Commerce Ministry spokesperson answers questions on the finding that EU foreign-subsidy investigation practices are improper extraterritorial jurisdiction measures]. 16 May 2026China's camp · government · in Chinese
  3. European Commission. Commission opens in-depth foreign subsidies investigation into Nuctech's activities in the threat detection systems sector. 11 December 2025European Union's camp · government
  4. European Commission. Commission sends Statement of Grounds to Temu over possible obstruction of inspection under the Foreign Subsidies Regulation. 31 July 2026European Union's camp · government
  5. European Commission. Review finds Foreign Subsidies Regulation fit for purpose, Commission considers targeted changes. 14 July 2026European Union's camp · government
  6. European Commission. Commission opens in-depth foreign subsidies investigation into JD.com's proposed acquisition of CECONOMY. 28 May 2026European Union's camp · government
  7. NATO. NATO member countries. 2026Independent camp · international organisation

All articles