Trade War

Macron says France will take some rare-earth output from Malaysia, which bars raw exports

Malaysia and France exchanged a critical-minerals memorandum on 17 November. Macron said France will take part of the output of a Carester-Malaco project and refine it at home. Anwar said Malaysia does not export raw materials.

Rare earths and export controls 17 November 2026

Malaysia and France exchanged a memorandum of understanding on critical minerals in Kuala Lumpur on 17 November 2026, one of seven documents exchanged during President Emmanuel Macron's two-day visit. Macron said France would take some of the rare-earth output of a project between the French firm Carester and Malaysia's Malaco Mining, which he said is due to start operating in early 2027. Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim said Malaysia does not export raw materials and called his country's approach to critical minerals unique.1 2 3 4

What the two leaders said

The memorandum was exchanged by Malaysia's deputy natural resources minister, Syed Ibrahim Syed Noh, and France's minister delegate for industry, Sébastien Martin, the national news agency Bernama reported. Its text was not in the reports read for this article.1

Macron, speaking at a business forum, called the Carester-Malaco agreement a cornerstone of co-operation on critical minerals and thanked Malaysia for speeding up permits. Bernama quoted him: "You will extract and process here, and we will have some offtakes and can refine at home." He said China had built up large capacity in rare earths, leaving many countries dependent on it. Before the visit he wrote on the platform X that he was coming to Malaysia in particular to diversify France's rare-earth supplies, RTM reported.2 4 12

Anwar, at the joint press conference, tied the arrangement to processing inside Malaysia. His words as rendered in Malay by the state broadcaster RTM:3

Malaysia tidak mengeksport bahan mentah, namun bagi kerjasama dengan Perancis, kita telah mengambil pendekatan tersebut kerana komitmen Perancis terhadap aktiviti pemprosesan serta kesediaan untuk bekerjasama dengan rakyat Malaysia sebagai satu pasukan.

Malaysia does not export raw materials, but for the co-operation with France we have taken that approach because of France's commitment to processing activities and its readiness to work with Malaysians as one team.3

Neither leader, in the reports read, said in what form France's share would leave Malaysia. That is the point on which the export rule turns, since Macron spoke of processing in Malaysia and further refining in France.2 3

The export ban and the pressure on it

Malaysia's federal government bans the export of raw rare earths in order to build processing and manufacturing at home, according to a study published in April 2026 by the ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute in Singapore. The New Straits Times, a Malaysian daily, described the measure in September as a moratorium on raw mineral exports for 2025 to 2027. Caixin Global, a Chinese business publication, dates a ban to 2024 and says it was extended in November 2025 to run through 2027.5 6 7

Domestic mining remains very limited, the New Straits Times reported: the only producing mine is at Gerik in Perak, and its rare-earth carbonate goes to China under an agreement signed before the moratorium. P. Loganathan, a geologist and fellow of the Academy of Sciences Malaysia, told the paper that the two Malaysian plants able to process such material, Lynas Malaysia in Kuantan and Malaco in Ipoh, were not yet processing locally produced carbonate for lack of feedstock. The official estimate of about 16 million tonnes of rare-earth resources is of inferred resources that further exploration would have to confirm, he said.6

Syed Ibrahim, the deputy minister who exchanged the French memorandum, was reported in August to have said that pressure to loosen the restriction was building from state governments and foreign investors, and that the United States, Australia, France and India had shown strong interest. Caixin, citing Bloomberg, said Malaysia was weighing a conditional easing. No such decision appears in the reports read here.7

The ISEAS study says authority is split: the federal government controls export policy and industrial strategy, while states control land and mining permits and may set their own royalties. It says some states have negotiated rare-earth partnerships separately from the federal government.5

What Malaysia promised Washington

Malaysia has also made the United States a commitment on critical-mineral exports. The joint statement issued by the White House on 26 October 2025, the day the two countries signed their Agreement on Reciprocal Trade, says:8 9

The agreement text published by Malaysia's trade ministry says it enters into force 60 days after both sides notify each other that their legal procedures are complete. The trade minister, Johari Abdul Ghani, said in July 2026 that this depends on ratification by both countries.9 10

The joint statement does not say whether "critical minerals or rare earth elements" includes unprocessed material, and the sources read do not show how Kuala Lumpur reconciles that commitment with the moratorium. Macron's stated aim, in RTM's account of his post, was to reduce dependence on limited sources of critical materials; the US text speaks of exports to the United States and sales to American companies.8 12

What comes next

A member of parliament was listed to ask the natural resources minister on 2 November for the state of the policy framework for the rare-earth industry, according to the order paper reported by RTM; the answer was not in the reports read. The Carester-Malaco project is due to start in early 2027 by Macron's account, and the moratorium, by the New Straits Times account, covers 2025 to 2027.2 6 11

Sources

  1. Bernama. Malaysia-Perancis Bertukar Tujuh Dokumen Kerjasama [Malaysia and France exchange seven co-operation documents]. 17 November 2026Malaysia's camp · state media · in Malay
  2. Bernama. Malaysia, France Elevate Ties To Strategic Partnership. 17 November 2026Malaysia's camp · state media reporting the French president
  3. Radio Televisyen Malaysia (RTM). Malaysia sasar pelaburan Perancis dalam pemprosesan REE [Malaysia targets French investment in rare-earth processing]. 17 November 2026Malaysia's camp · state media reporting the prime minister · in Malay
  4. BernamaBiz. France To Secure Rare Earth Supply In Malaysian Deal – Macron. 17 November 2026Malaysia's camp · state media reporting the French president
  5. ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute. Ambition Without Alignment: Managing Malaysia's Rare Earth Value Chain, by Tricia Yeoh (Trends in Southeast Asia 2026/14). April 2026Independent camp · think tank
  6. New Straits Times. From mine to magnet: Malaysia's rare earths need more than a ban. 28 September 2026Malaysia's camp · press
  7. Caixin Global. Malaysia Weighs Conditional Easing of Raw Rare Earth Export Ban. 5 August 2026China's camp · press citing Bloomberg
  8. The White House. Joint Statement on United States-Malaysia Agreement on Reciprocal Trade. 26 October 2025United States' camp · government
  9. Ministry of Investment, Trade and Industry of Malaysia. Agreement on Reciprocal Trade (ART). 22 May 2026Malaysia's camp · government
  10. Utusan Malaysia. Malaysia diberi dua tahun gubal undang-undang buruh paksa [Malaysia given two years to draft forced-labour law]. 25 July 2026Malaysia's camp · press reporting the trade minister · in Malay
  11. Radio Televisyen Malaysia (RTM), carrying Bernama. Dewan Rakyat: Dasar industri REE, rawatan obesiti jadi tumpuan [Dewan Rakyat: rare-earth industry policy and obesity treatment in focus]. 2 November 2026Malaysia's camp · state media · in Malay
  12. Radio Televisyen Malaysia (RTM), carrying Bernama. Lawatan Macron ke Malaysia tumpu usaha pelbagaikan bekalan unsur nadir bumi [Macron's visit to Malaysia focuses on diversifying rare-earth supply]. 15 November 2026Malaysia's camp · state media reporting the French president · in Malay

All articles