Trade War

Indonesia's claim for up to $5.6 billion a year against the EU over palm oil is on hold

Indonesia asked the WTO in March to let it retaliate against the EU over palm-oil biofuel rules. The arbitration has been suspended since 29 June pending any compliance proceedings. The WTO's case summary records no compliance panel request.

The law 17 November 2026

Indonesia's request to retaliate against the European Union over its treatment of palm-oil biofuel is suspended at the World Trade Organization, and the next move is Jakarta's. Indonesia asked in March 2026 for authority to suspend trade concessions worth between US$2.8 billion and US$5.6 billion a year. Since 29 June the arbitration on that figure has been on hold under an understanding between the two sides, which lets Indonesia ask for a compliance panel after 10 September, the date by which the EU expected its amended rule to be in force. The WTO's summary of the case, read on 17 November, records no such request.1 2 3

What the panel decided, and how each side reads it

The case, numbered DS593, concerns the EU's 2018 renewable energy directive and a Commission regulation that classes palm oil as a feedstock with a high risk of indirect land-use change, the EU's term for the risk that growing it for fuel pushes farming into forest and peatland. Biofuel in that class is capped and phased out of what counts towards the EU's renewable energy targets.1 5 7

The panel report was circulated on 10 January 2025 and adopted on 24 February 2025. It found that the cap and phase-out treated Indonesian palm-oil biofuel less favourably than like products from the EU and from other countries, and that the EU had failed to review its data in time and had designed and applied its low-risk certification defectively. It also rejected a series of Indonesia's claims, among them that the measure was more trade-restrictive than necessary, and it accepted that the measure relates to conserving exhaustible natural resources and protecting life or health.1

Each side took what suited it. The Commission headed its statement of 10 January 2025 "WTO confirms validity of EU climate-based actions in renewable energy dispute brought by Indonesia" and said the shortcomings found would be adjusted. Indonesia's trade minister, Budi Santoso, said in a press release reported on 26 February 2026 that the ruling showed EU policy discriminated against Indonesian palm-oil biofuel.5 6

Kami mendesak UE untuk segera mematuhi putusan Panel WTO agar akses pasar produk minyak sawit Indonesia ke UE dapat segera pulih.

We urge the EU to comply at once with the WTO panel's ruling so that market access for Indonesian palm oil products to the EU can soon be restored.6

From deadline to retaliation request

The two sides agreed that the EU had until 24 February 2026 to comply. On 6 March Indonesia asked the Dispute Settlement Body, the WTO council that oversees disputes, for authority to suspend concessions, on the ground that the EU had missed the date. Budi Santoso said in a statement of 7 March that the suspension would focus on goods but was open to other sectors.1 4

At a special meeting on 19 March, Indonesia put the level at an estimated US$2.8 billion to US$5.6 billion a year, which it said reflected the harm to its palm oil industry since the EU measures took effect. The EU said it "strongly objects to the level of suspension" and that it had offered Indonesia a sequencing agreement, an arrangement on the order of the legal steps. Indonesia answered that the offer came too late for it to consult its industry. The matter went to arbitration, during which, the EU recalled, concessions may not be suspended.2 8

The June understanding

Three months later the two governments told the WTO they had agreed a sequencing procedure. The communication, dated 15 June 2026, records the EU's statement that amendments to its 2019 regulation were adopted on 10 April 2026 and "are expected to enter into force no later than 10 September 2026". If Indonesia considers after that date that the EU still does not comply, it may request a compliance panel under Article 21.5 of the WTO's dispute rules, and the EU must accept the panel at the first meeting where the request appears.3

The same text sets deadlines the parties promise to help meet: 90 days for the compliance panel's report and 60 days for the arbitrator once the arbitration resumes. If the WTO's Appellate Body is not functioning when the compliance report appears, a party wishing to appeal is to try to do so through arbitration under Article 25 of the dispute rules. The arbitrator suspended its work from 29 June 2026 until either side asks for it to resume, which the understanding allows only after a final ruling that the EU has not complied.1 3

What is not known

This site could not confirm from the documents it opened whether the amended EU regulation entered into force by 10 September. The Commission's biofuels page says only that it adopted a report with updated data on 20 January 2026 and published a draft amending regulation. Nor did the pages read contain an Indonesian government assessment of the amended rule.7

The Indonesian biofuel producers' association backed the March request. Its deputy chairman, Catra De Thouars, said the calculated yearly loss of potential export value was very large; the report of his statement gives no figure.4

The open question is whether Indonesia accepts the amended regulation or asks for a compliance panel. The June text provides for the arbitration on Indonesia's retaliation claim to resume after a final compliance ruling against the EU.3

Sources

  1. World Trade Organization. DS593: European Union - Certain Measures Concerning Palm Oil and Oil Palm Crop-Based Biofuels (case summary). read 17 November 2026Independent camp · international body
  2. World Trade Organization. Arbitrator to set level of trade suspension in Indonesia-EU palm oil biofuels dispute. 19 March 2026Independent camp · international body
  3. World Trade Organization, document WT/DS593/23, as hosted by italaw. Understanding between Indonesia and the European Union regarding procedures under Articles 21 and 22 of the DSU. 19 June 2026Independent camp · WTO document, joint communication of Indonesia and the EU
  4. Investortrust. Indonesia Lanjutkan Proses Sengketa Minyak Sawit dengan Uni Eropa di WTO [Indonesia continues the palm oil dispute with the European Union at the WTO]. 7 March 2026Indonesia's camp · press reporting the trade ministry · in Indonesian
  5. European Commission, Directorate-General for Trade and Economic Security. WTO confirms validity of EU climate-based actions in renewable energy dispute brought by Indonesia. 10 January 2025European Union's camp · government
  6. Katadata. Indonesia Minta Uni Eropa Patuhi Putusan WTO agar Akses Pasar Sawit Pulih [Indonesia asks the European Union to comply with the WTO ruling so palm oil market access recovers]. 26 February 2026Indonesia's camp · press reporting the trade ministry · in Indonesian
  7. European Commission, Directorate-General for Energy. Biofuels. read 17 November 2026European Union's camp · government
  8. European External Action Service. EU statements as delivered at the special DSB meeting, 19 March 2026. 19 March 2026European Union's camp · government

All articles