Trade War

Hong Kong's WTO win over the US rule to mark its goods "China" is still stuck on appeal in 2026

A WTO panel ruled in December 2022 that the US rule requiring Hong Kong goods to be marked as made in China breaks trade rules. The US appealed to a body with no judges in January 2023, and the WTO record shows no ruling on the appeal since.

The law 18 November 2026

Nearly four years after a World Trade Organization panel ruled for Hong Kong, the dispute over the US rule that Hong Kong goods must be labelled as made in China has not moved. The WTO's record of the case, numbered DS597, shows nothing after the US appeal of 26 January 2023 and Hong Kong's reply of 1 February 2023, with no appeal report and no adoption of the ruling. The body that would hear the appeal still has no members.1 6

The measure

US law requires imported goods to carry the English name of their country of origin. Goods made in Hong Kong were marked "Hong Kong" until 2020. On 14 July 2020 Executive Order 13936 suspended the separate treatment of Hong Kong under several US statutes, including the marking statute. The WTO Secretariat's summary places the order after events that included China's adoption of a security law for Hong Kong in 2020. US Customs and Border Protection then gave notice that Hong Kong goods "must be marked to indicate 'China.'"1 4 5

Hong Kong, a special administrative region of China, is a WTO member in its own right under the name Hong Kong, China. It requested consultations with the United States on 30 October 2020, and a panel was established on 22 February 2021. Thirteen members reserved rights as third parties, among them China, the European Union, Japan and Canada.1

What the panel decided

The panel report was circulated on 21 December 2022. According to the WTO Secretariat's summary, the panel found that the United States itself determines the origin of the goods to be Hong Kong, China, and then requires them to carry the name of another WTO member. Goods of any other member carry their own name. The panel held that this difference worked to the detriment of Hong Kong products and was inconsistent with Article IX:1 of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994, which requires equal treatment in marking rules.1

The United States invoked Article XXI(b), the security exception, and argued that the exception is for each member alone to judge. The panel disagreed: it held that it could review whether the conditions of the exception were met, and that they were not. It read "emergency in international relations" as a state of affairs of the utmost gravity, close to a breakdown in relations, and concluded that the situation, although of serious concern to the United States and others on human rights grounds, had not reached that threshold.1

Hong Kong's commerce secretary, Algernon Yau, said on the day of the report:

我們歡迎專家組充分肯定中國香港作為單獨關稅區的地位。

We welcome that the Panel has fully affirmed the status of Hong Kong, China as a separate customs territory.3

He said he had written to the US Trade Representative urging the United States to withdraw the requirement.3

The appeal

On 26 January 2023 the United States notified its decision to appeal. The Appellate Body is not operating: its seats are vacant, and the United States has declined to support the proposal of most members to fill them. Several members describe an appeal lodged in this situation as an appeal "into the void". Hong Kong, China told the WTO on 1 February 2023 that it considered all deadlines suspended, noted that the United States had filed no written submission, and reserved its own right to appeal.1 2

At the Dispute Settlement Body meeting of 27 January 2023, Hong Kong, China said the United States was "taking advantage of the impasse" and "evading its responsibility" to comply, according to the WTO's account. The United States said its actions rested on "well-grounded determinations implicating US essential security interests relating to democracy and human rights", and that it fundamentally disagreed with a reading under which a state must wait for a breakdown in relations before acting.2

Where it stands in 2026

The WTO's 2026 news items on dispute settlement, read for this article, do not report any step in DS597. At the Dispute Settlement Body meeting of 25 September 2026, Colombia introduced, on behalf of 130 members and for the 100th time, a proposal to start filling the Appellate Body's vacancies. The United States said it did not support it.6

On the American side, one part of the 2020 framework has changed. The national emergency declared in Executive Order 13936 was not continued beyond 14 July 2026, and the US Treasury ended the sanctions that rested only on emergency powers. The Hong Kong government called this a positive adjustment of US policy and asked Washington to restore normal economic and trade exchanges.7 8

That emergency is a matter of US domestic law and is distinct from the "emergency in international relations" test the panel applied. The marking requirement was made under the Hong Kong Policy Act, and the US State Department said in April 2026, before the emergency lapsed, that Executive Order 13936 "remains in effect". None of the documents read for this article withdraws the customs notice of 2020.4 7 9

The open questions are whether US Customs changes the marking rule after the lapse of the emergency, and whether either party asks the WTO to close the case. Neither has been announced in the sources read.1 6

Sources

  1. World Trade Organization. DS597: United States, Origin Marking Requirement (dispute summary and key dates). accessed 18 November 2026Independent camp · international body
  2. World Trade Organization. Dispute Settlement Body meeting of 27 January 2023, news item. 27 January 2023Independent camp · international body
  3. Hong Kong SAR Government. 香港特區政府歡迎世貿裁定美國產地來源標記規定不符合世貿規則 [HKSAR Government welcomes WTO ruling that the US origin marking requirement is inconsistent with WTO rules]. 21 December 2022Hong Kong's camp · government · in Chinese
  4. US Customs and Border Protection, Federal Register. Country of Origin Marking of Products of Hong Kong. 11 August 2020United States' camp · government
  5. The President, Federal Register. Executive Order 13936 of July 14, 2020, The President's Executive Order on Hong Kong Normalization. 17 July 2020United States' camp · government
  6. World Trade Organization. Panel to review EU carbon border adjustment mechanism and emissions trading scheme (Dispute Settlement Body meeting of 25 September 2026). 25 September 2026Independent camp · international body
  7. Office of Foreign Assets Control, Federal Register. Notice of OFAC Sanctions Action. 22 July 2026United States' camp · government
  8. Hong Kong SAR Government. 特區政府就美國不再延續涉港國家緊急狀態的聲明 [Statement of the HKSAR Government on the United States no longer continuing the national emergency relating to Hong Kong]. 17 July 2026Hong Kong's camp · government · in Chinese
  9. US Department of State. Hong Kong Conditions Report 2026. 16 April 2026United States' camp · government

All articles