Trade WarFigures as of 16 November 2026

WTO cases against US tariffs sit in consultations while the appeals bench stays empty

China's and Canada's WTO complaints against the 2025 US tariffs are still listed as in consultations. A proposal to refill the Appellate Body failed for the 100th time in September, and Washington has appealed one lost ruling to the empty bench.

The law 17 November 2026

The World Trade Organization's own case pages still list the complaints that China and Canada filed against the United States' 2025 tariffs as "in consultations", the first stage of a dispute, with no panel of judges requested. Only Brazil has moved further: its request for a panel is on the agenda for 24 November 2026. Any ruling that follows can be appealed to a body that has had no members since 2019, and a proposal to refill it was turned down by the United States for the 100th time on 25 September.1 2 3 4

Three complaints that have not moved

A WTO dispute begins with a request for consultations. If 60 days pass without a settlement, the complaining country may ask the Dispute Settlement Body, on which every member sits, to set up a panel.5

The WTO's summaries of all three are marked as current only to 30 April 2025, and none records a panel request.1 2 6

The tariffs they challenge no longer exist. They were imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, and the US Supreme Court ruled on 20 February 2026 that tariffs under that law were invalid, as Malaysia's trade minister among others told his parliament. The measures fell without any WTO finding.11

Brazil's case, DS646, concerns tariffs that are still in force: a 25% duty and a 12.5% duty, both imposed in July 2026 under Section 301 of the US Trade Act of 1974, which allows tariffs after an investigation of a foreign practice. Brazil asked for consultations on 27 July. The Brazilian broadcaster SBT reports that the panel request goes to the Dispute Settlement Body on 24 November, that Washington can refuse it once, and that it cannot block it alone at the following meeting on 17 December.3 5

A surcharge reviewed after it had ended

One 2026 measure went through a different WTO channel. The United States notified its 10% surcharge on all imports, imposed on 20 February under Section 122 of the Trade Act, to the Committee on Balance-of-Payments Restrictions, citing "fundamental international payment problems". Several members asked for consultations, which were held on 5 May and resumed on 2 October.7

By then the surcharge had expired. The committee's report, adopted on 12 October, records the outcome in one sentence: "Members noted that the US measure was terminated on 24 July, thereby concluding the consultations." The report goes to the General Council, and contains no finding on whether the surcharge was justified.7

What happens to a ruling: the solar and battery case

The one recent case that China has won against the United States shows where a panel ruling leads. On 30 January 2026 a panel found that clean-energy tax credits under the US Inflation Reduction Act, which favour projects using American-made goods, broke WTO rules. China's Commerce Ministry welcomed it.8

中方对专家组作出的客观、公正裁决表示欢迎和赞赏。

China welcomes and appreciates the objective and impartial ruling made by the panel.8

At the Dispute Settlement Body on 24 February the United States announced that it was appealing, and adoption of the report was taken off the agenda. The US said the panel had avoided meaningful findings on China's non-market policies and its dominance in renewable energy. China said it was disappointed that the appeal had been lodged "before a non-functioning Appellate Body". The European Union, a third party, said the case showed the need for appeal review. An appeal that cannot be heard leaves the ruling without legal force.9

One hundred refusals

The Appellate Body is meant to have seven members, and all seven seats are vacant. At each monthly meeting Colombia, speaking for 130 members, proposes to start selecting new ones. The 25 September meeting was the 100th time. The WTO's French-language summary records the reply.4

Les États-Unis ont dit qu'ils ne soutenaient pas la décision proposée.

The United States said that it did not support the proposed decision.4

Washington's position, as stated in June, is that "repeating this agenda item, which does not itself propose any reform" does not help, and that its fundamental concerns about WTO dispute settlement have not been addressed. Colombia's group answers that talks on reform should not prevent the Appellate Body from working, and that members are obliged to fill vacancies as they arise. More than 20 members spoke in support in September.4 10

Some members use a substitute. Several delegations in September urged others to join the multi-party interim appeal arbitration arrangement, under which participants agree to settle appeals among themselves by arbitration, and Cambodia was welcomed as its newest member. The United States is not described as a participant in the sources read, so the arrangement does not reach cases against it.4

SBT's report on Brazil's case makes the same point from the complainant's side: the losing party may appeal, but the appeals body "está desfalcado e inoperante", understaffed and inoperative, because the United States blocked the appointments. A panel, it says, takes 60 to 90 days to compose and about a year to rule.3

The next dated event is the Dispute Settlement Body meeting on 24 November 2026, where Brazil's panel request is listed and Colombia's proposal is due to be put again. The WTO's report of the 27 October meeting was not found for this article, so the count of refusals may already stand above 100.3 4

Sources

  1. World Trade Organization. DS633: United States, Additional Tariff Measures on Goods from China. Summary current to 30 April 2025, read 17 November 2026Independent camp · international organisation
  2. World Trade Organization. DS634: United States, Additional Import Duties on Goods from Canada. Summary current to 30 April 2025, read 17 November 2026Independent camp · international organisation
  3. SBT News. Sem acordo, Brasil avança e abre disputa na OMC contra EUA [Without agreement, Brazil moves ahead and opens a WTO dispute against the US]. 13 November 2026Brazil's camp · press reporting government officials · in Portuguese
  4. Organisation mondiale du commerce. Réunion de l'Organe de règlement des différends du 25 septembre 2026 [Dispute Settlement Body meeting of 25 September 2026]. 25 September 2026Independent camp · international organisation · in French
  5. World Trade Organization. Brazil initiates WTO dispute regarding US additional duties (DS646). 30 July 2026Independent camp · international organisation
  6. World Trade Organization. DS638: United States, Universal and Country-specific Additional Duties on Imports from China. Summary current to 30 April 2025, read 17 November 2026Independent camp · international organisation
  7. World Trade Organization. Committee on Balance-of-Payments Restrictions concludes consultations on the US import surcharge. 12 October 2026Independent camp · international organisation
  8. Xinhua (新华网). 世贸组织专家组裁定美通胀削减法清洁能源补贴违规 [WTO panel rules clean-energy subsidies under the US Inflation Reduction Act break the rules]. 31 January 2026China's camp · state media reporting the ministry · in Chinese
  9. World Trade Organization. Dispute Settlement Body meeting of 24 February 2026. 24 February 2026Independent camp · international organisation
  10. Third World Network. Trade: US again extends Appellate Body paralysis amid DSS reform talks. 25 June 2026Independent camp · non-governmental news service
  11. Berita RTM. Perjanjian ART belum diluluskan secara rasmi, Malaysia terus runding dengan AS [The ART has not been formally approved, Malaysia keeps negotiating with the US]. 23 June 2026Malaysia's camp · state media reporting the trade minister · in Malay

All articles