The US International Trade Commission was evenly divided on 13 November 2026 on whether imports of lamb meat are a substantial cause of serious injury to American sheep producers. Three commissioners said yes and three said no. Under the safeguard law a tie does not end the case. It moves to a remedy phase, and both sets of findings go to President Trump, who decides whether to impose a tariff or a quota. No new duty applies in the meantime.1 2 3
What a safeguard is, and how the vote fell
The case is brought under Section 201 of the Trade Act of 1974, the "global safeguard" law. It allows temporary limits on imports from all countries when a surge in imports seriously injures an American industry. Unlike anti-dumping or subsidy cases, it does not require proof that foreign suppliers did anything unfair.1
The American Sheep Industry Association asked for the investigation in October 2025 on behalf of 42 state associations, and the US Trade Representative referred it to the commission on 13 July 2026. The commission heard the injury arguments on 16 October.2 4
According to R-CALF USA, a ranchers' group that took part on the producers' side, Chairman Brett Doyle and Commissioners Jason Kearns and Bart Thanhauser voted that imports are injuring the industry. Commissioners Peter-Anthony Pappas, David Foley and Samuel Negatu voted that they are not.5
The three commissioners who found injury named Australia alone as a substantial cause of it. They found that imports from Canada and Mexico do not contribute importantly, and that imports from a list of free-trade partners, among them South Korea, Colombia, Peru and Singapore, are not individually a substantial cause. R-CALF's account gives no separate finding for New Zealand. The commission's own news release could not be opened for this article, so the detail of the vote rests on the participants' accounts, which agree.5 3
What each side argues
The American producers say cheaper imports set the price they can charge. R-CALF, citing the commission's data, says US lamb consumption rose 17.3% from 2021 to 2025 while domestic shipments fell 10.5%, and that imports were priced below American lamb in 144 of 154 quarterly comparisons.1
Australia supplies about 75% of US lamb imports, the Australian farm paper Stock & Land reports, and the United States is the largest market for Australian lamb, taking 85,200 tonnes in the year to June 2026. Australian lamb has paid a 12.5% US tariff since July under the separate forced-labour tariffs.3 6
The Australian Meat Industry Council and Sheep Producers Australia said in a joint statement that Australian lamb complements American production and is neither a cause nor a threat of serious injury. The council's chief executive, Tim Ryan, said imports "fill seasonal gaps in domestic supply and help maintain the critical mass the category needs to remain viable". The two bodies added that current trade arrangements stay unchanged until the end of March 2027 while the process runs. Australia's agriculture minister, Julie Collins, said in July that the government was disappointed by the investigation.3 4
New Zealand's Meat Industry Association said in July that New Zealand supplies about a quarter of US lamb imports, just under 27,000 tonnes a year on average, and that its exports have not damaged American producers.7
R-CALF lists nine foreign governments and the European Union as parties. Australia, New Zealand and the United Kingdom opposed relief, and Chile and Spain asked for their products to be excluded.1
What happens next
The timetable was set in July, when the United States notified the investigation to the World Trade Organization (WTO). The notice, in the WTO's Spanish text, provided for exactly this outcome:
En caso de que la Comisión formule una determinación positiva de existencia de daño grave o de que haya empate de votos sobre la cuestión de la existencia de daño grave en el caso objeto de esta investigación, el 1 de diciembre de 2026 se celebrará una audiencia sobre la cuestión de la reparación.
If the Commission makes an affirmative determination of serious injury, or if the votes are tied on the question of serious injury in this investigation, a hearing on the question of remedy will be held on 1 December 2026.8
The commission must send its report, with the remedy recommendations of both groups of commissioners, to the president by 11 January 2027. The sheep association says the president then has 60 days to accept a recommendation or choose a remedy of his own, and that any measure would take effect about 15 days after he proclaims it. Stock & Land lists additional tariffs, import quotas and tariff-rate quotas as the possible remedies. Neither American group has said publicly what rate it is asking for.2 3 1
The 1999 precedent
The United States has done this before. In July 1999 it imposed a tariff-rate quota on lamb from Australia and New Zealand after a safeguard investigation. Both countries complained to the WTO. A panel and then the Appellate Body found, among other faults, that the United States had not shown the import surge resulted from unforeseen developments and had wrongly counted growers and feeders of live lambs as part of the lamb-meat industry. The measure ended on 15 November 2001.9
R-CALF's briefs again urged the commission to include sheep growers and lamb feeders in its injury analysis. Whether the commission did so will be clear only when its report is published. The next dated step is the remedy hearing on 1 December 2026.1 2