Trade WarFigures as of 16 November 2026

Trade court asks forced-labour tariff challengers which countries they import from

Six weeks after hearing the case against the 10% and 12.5% tariffs on 60 economies, the US Court of International Trade has not ruled. Its latest order hints that any relief could be limited to some countries.

The law 16 November 2026

The US Court of International Trade has still not ruled on the challenge to the forced-labour tariffs that took effect on 24 July 2026. On 4 November the three judges ordered the challengers to file declarations, by 10 November, naming every country or economy they import from. The court did not say how it would use the lists, but the judges had raised at the hearing the possibility of relief limited to those countries. The tariffs of 10% or 12.5% on goods from 60 economies remain in force in the meantime.1 2 3

Who sued, and when

The tariffs rest on Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, which lets the US Trade Representative act against a foreign practice found to be unreasonable and to burden American commerce. The Trade Representative found that 60 economies, which supply 99.4% of US imports, fail to ban imports of goods made with forced labour or fail to enforce such a ban.4 5

The first suit was filed on the day the tariffs began, 24 July 2026, by Burlap & Barrel, a spice importer, and Collective Horology, a watch retailer. They are represented by the Liberty Justice Center, a legal advocacy group. A coalition of 25 states sued on 3 August.5 6

The suits are consolidated as In re Section 301 Forced Labor Cases, number 26-03555. The suit by the toy maker Learning Resources is the lead test case, and the plaintiffs also include hand2mind.3 7

What each side argues

The challengers say Section 301 is a tool against a specific practice by a specific country, and that no such findings were made. They argue that the Trade Representative did not link the tariff on each economy to anything that economy does, that the rates bear no relation to the amount of forced-labour goods involved, and that the tariff covers products with no connection to forced labour. The states add that the measure was designed to replace the Section 122 surcharge that expired the same day, and that an accused economy has no way to get out of it. They also argue that reading the statute this widely would hand Congress's tariff power to the president.5 6 7

The government says the action follows the long-standing American policy against forced-labour imports and that the determinations are largely beyond review by a court because the president directed them. It has asked the court to dismiss the case.1 7

What the judges have asked

At the hearing in New York on 30 September, Judge Timothy Reif pressed the Justice Department's lawyer, Eric Hamilton, to name the provision on which the Trade Representative relied. Judge Jennifer Choe-Groves said there was "not a lot of depth" in the evidence offered. The third judge is Lisa Wang. Pratik Shah, for the challengers, asked the court to decide the legal questions and not to send the matter back for the agency to add to its record.3

Two days later the court put five written questions to both sides, with answers due on 16 October. They asked which provision the unreasonableness finding rests on, whether the Trade Representative must weigh a country's level of economic development, and whether the plaintiffs can challenge the action against all 60 economies or only against those they buy from.8

The order of 4 November follows from that last question. At the hearing the judges and the small businesses' lawyer had discussed relief covering only the roughly two dozen countries those firms trade with.1 2

How the targeted governments describe the tariff

China, which pays the 12.5% rate, rejects the premise. Its Commerce Ministry said on 27 July that China opposes forced labour and that the United States has itself not ratified the 1930 Forced Labour Convention.9

此次又以“强迫劳动”为由发起301调查并加征单边关税,是典型的单边主义、保护主义行为,中方对此坚决反对。

This time it has again cited "forced labour" to open a Section 301 investigation and impose unilateral tariffs. This is typical unilateralism and protectionism, and China firmly opposes it.9

The ministry's statement treats the tariff as a replacement for the ones struck down, which is also the challengers' argument in court. It says Washington promised that replacement tariffs on Chinese goods would not exceed 20%. The US government has not confirmed a promise in those terms.9

Japan's trade promotion agency, JETRO, reported the measure to Japanese exporters without comment from Tokyo. It noted that for Japan, South Korea and Switzerland the ordinary duty and the new tariff together come to 12.5%, and that goods already paying 12.5% or more pay nothing extra.4

What a ruling would and would not do

No court order has suspended collection. One law firm's review notes that importers have no way to recover these duties unless the court sets the determinations aside, and that it knows of no class action covering them.7

The court has given no date for its decision. The open question is the one the judges themselves raised: whether a ruling against the government would remove the tariff for all 60 economies or only for the countries named in the declarations due on 10 November.1 8

Sources

  1. World Trade Scanner. Court Orders Trump to Declare List of Countries using Forced Labour for Section 301 Tariff. 6 November 2026Independent camp · trade press
  2. Inside U.S. Trade. Court of International Trade (topic page, headlines to 11 November 2026). 11 November 2026Independent camp · trade press
  3. ExFreight. Trade Court Probes Section 301 Forced-Labor Tariffs. 1 October 2026Industry camp · logistics company news
  4. JETRO (Japan External Trade Organization). 米USTR、強制労働産品の輸入禁止措置を巡り、日本含む60カ国・地域に301条関税賦課を最終決定 [USTR makes final decision to impose Section 301 tariffs on 60 countries and regions including Japan over bans on imports of forced-labour goods]. 24 July 2026Japan's camp · government trade agency · in Japanese
  5. Liberty Justice Center. Court of International Trade to Hear Challenge to Sweeping Section 301 Tariffs. 29 September 2026Plaintiffs' camp · plaintiffs' lawyers
  6. Supply Chain Dive. 25 states sue Trump over Section 301 forced labor tariffs. 4 August 2026United States' camp · press
  7. Troutman Pepper Locke. Getting Duties Back: Where Recovery Stands Under IEEPA, Section 122, and Section 301 Forced Labor Tariffs. 12 October 2026Independent camp · law firm analysis
  8. Trade Law Daily. CIT Orders Parties in Section 301 Case to File Briefs Answering Judges' Questions. 5 October 2026Independent camp · trade press
  9. Xinhua, carrying the Ministry of Commerce. 商务部新闻发言人就美发布“强迫劳动”301调查最终措施答记者问 [Commerce Ministry spokesperson answers a reporter's question on the US final measures in the "forced labour" Section 301 investigation]. 27 July 2026China's camp · government · in Chinese

All articles