Trade WarFigures as of 16 November 2026

Former US trade officials tell the court the 1930 law behind the Canada tariffs is dead

Carla Hills, Alan Wolff and Warren Maruyama filed a brief on 11 November saying Section 338 was replaced by Section 301 in 1974. It is one of five briefs backing the importer challenging the 50% tariffs on Canadian goods. The government answers by 11 December.

The law 17 November 2026

Three former senior American trade officials have asked the US Court of International Trade to strike down the 50% tariffs on Canadian goods. Their brief, dated 11 November 2026, argues that Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, the law the tariffs rest on, was superseded decades ago and can no longer be used at all. The Liberty Justice Center, the legal group representing the importer that brought the case, announced on 16 November that five such briefs had been filed in its support.1 2

This site reported on 16 November that the case, Gellert Global Group v. Trump, will be heard on 20 January 2027. What is new is who has lined up behind the importer and the argument they add, which goes further than the importer's own.2 3

Who signed

The brief is from Carla Hills, the US Trade Representative from 1989 to 1993, who negotiated the North American Free Trade Agreement; Alan Wolff, who as a government lawyer drafted the first version of Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 and was later deputy director-general of the World Trade Organization; and Warren Maruyama, general counsel to the Trade Representative from 2007 to 2009. Section 301 is the law normally used against unfair foreign trade practices. It requires an investigation, public hearings and consultations with the country concerned.1

What they argue

The central claim is that Congress, by writing Section 301, replaced Section 338 without needing to repeal it. Lawyers call this implied repeal: where a later law covers the same subject and adds stricter conditions, the later law governs. The brief concedes that courts rarely find it. It says this is the rare case, because the two laws address the same thing, discrimination against American commerce, and the only reason to use the older one is to avoid the procedures of the newer.1

For evidence the three rely partly on their own memories. Mr Wolff states that he attended every committee drafting session on the 1974 act and that Section 338 was never considered. The brief says nine administrations, from President Ford to President Trump's first term, treated the provision as a dead letter, and that the congressional compilations of trade statutes published from 1989 to 2010 left it out. Its conclusion reads: "Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 is not dormant; it is dead."1

The brief then makes four narrower points in case the court finds the law still valid:

The signatories are not opponents of tariffs as such. They praise the first Trump administration's Section 301 case against China for its report and hearings, and note that Section 301 has no ceiling on the rate. They warn that upholding Section 338 would give this and future presidents a tool that could be used to bring back the tariffs the courts have struck down.1

The other briefs

The Liberty Justice Center lists four more. Trade scholars Gregory Shaffer, Jennifer Hillman and Peter Harrell argue that Section 338 allows only duties in proportion to a measured burden. Advancing American Freedom, a group founded by the former vice-president Mike Pence, filed with the Tax Foundation and other free-market organisations. Philip Zelikow and Robert Zoellick, the latter another former Trade Representative, argue the law was meant for countries outside America's reciprocal trade arrangements, not for a treaty partner. Barry Appleton, a trade lawyer, argues that the different cheese quotas Canada gives the United States and the European Union under separate agreements are not discrimination. Only the first of these briefs was read for this article.2

What the government says

The Justice Department has not yet answered in court; its response to the importer's motion is due on 11 December. Newsweek reports the White House position as being that the measures are needed to protect American businesses from unfair treatment, and that the Trade Representative's office did not reply to its request for comment. The proclamations of July 2026 found that Canada discriminates through provincial bans on American alcohol, its dairy quotas and its tariff on American vehicles.1 4

Canada's position

Canada is not a party. Its government is negotiating with Washington, and Prime Minister Mark Carney said on 1 November, as reported in French by the Quebec outlet Noovo, that an agreement would have to be one that5

«respecterait pleinement les langues, la culture et la souveraineté du Canada»

"would fully respect the languages, the culture and the sovereignty of Canada"5

No agreement has been announced. The case is before Judges Claire Kelly, Joseph Laroski and Kara Westercamp, with the government's brief due on 11 December and the hearing on 20 January 2027.1 4 2

Sources

  1. Carla A. Hills, Alan Wm. Wolff and Warren H. Maruyama (filed in Gellert Global Group Corp. v. Trump, US Court of International Trade, No. 26-04636). Amici Curiae Brief of Former U.S. Trade Officials in Support of Plaintiff. 11 November 2026Plaintiffs' camp · court filing supporting the plaintiff
  2. Liberty Justice Center. Former U.S. Trade Representatives, Scholars Back Liberty Justice Center's Challenge to Trump's Canadian Tariffs. 16 November 2026Plaintiffs' camp · plaintiffs' lawyers
  3. Sandler, Travis & Rosenberg. In the News: More Talk About Tariffs. 16 November 2026Independent camp · trade consultancy press review
  4. Newsweek. Former US Trade Officials Challenge Trump's Canada Tariffs. November 2026United States' camp · press
  5. Noovo Info. Le Canada et les États-Unis ont «l'idée d'une très bonne entente», selon Donald Trump [Canada and the United States have "the idea of a very good deal", says Donald Trump]. 1 November 2026Canada's camp · press · in French

All articles